Monday, November 30 , 2015, 7:12 pm | Fair 50º

Joe Conason: Will Catholic Bishops and the Religious Right Save Obama?

Crusade against the president's 'compromise' ensuring full access to birth control will only hurt Republicans

By Joe Conason |

What is most striking about the showdown over contraceptive freedom is not the political victory that President Barack Obama earned by standing up for women’s reproductive rights, although his Republican adversaries are certainly helping him make the most of it. Those adversaries don’t seem to realize they have fallen into a trap, whether the White House set them up intentionally or not.

While the Catholic bishops and their allies on the religious right insist that this is an argument over the First Amendment, their true, long-standing purpose now stands revealed to the public.

They would begin by imposing their dogma on every woman unlucky enough to work for an employer who shares it — an agenda that is deeply unpopular even among the Catholic faithful, let alone the rest of the American electorate. Then they would impose it on everyone, as the theorists of the religious right suggest every time they deny the separation of church and state.

The bishops have nothing to lose except their flock, whose respect for the hierarchy has plunged anyway over its resistance to reform and its failure to punish abuses far graver and more sinful than contraception. If they had to stand for election, not many of them would be left standing. And if they had to face a referendum on this current matter, they would lose resoundingly to the president, according to the latest survey data.

In a poll taken last Friday for the Coalition to Protect Women’s Health Care, Public Policy Polling found that 57 percent of Catholic voters endorse the Obama “compromise” that would ensure continued prescription birth control for women working in religious institutions, without requiring those institutions to pay directly for that coverage. Only 29 percent sided with the bishops, the religious right and the Republicans, while 5 percent actually think the religious institutions should pay for contraceptive coverage regardless of their doctrine.

The cross-tabs of the PPP poll show that Latino Catholics, Catholic independent voters and Catholic women support the Obama solution by wide margins. (The most recent poll by Fox News Channel shows the same overwhelming approval for the president’s position among the general public, with 61 percent of voters on his side vs. only 34 percent against.)

Those statistics are no threat to the bishops, of course, but represent a profound problem for the Republican leaders and candidates who have signed up for this male geriatric crusade against modernity. Mitt Romney, for instance, seems to believe that by stoking evangelical paranoia about a supposed “war on religion” by Obama, he will subdue evangelical paranoia about his Mormonism (which, by the way, expressly permits birth control). His pandering commenced when he announced his 2012 candidacy, but grew still more intense this week when he accused the president of perpetrating an “assault” on religion.

Such tactics are unlikely to placate the prejudices arrayed against Romney — and even if they did, he will pay a very high price next fall for joining the angriest and most extreme culture warriors on this issue. Congressional Republicans will be courting the same danger if, as promised, they propose legislation that would overturn the Obama compromise and deprive women working for religious institutions of equal rights to contraceptive services.

The president should hold fast. He has proved that it is possible to uphold the principle of full access to birth control, which has been the pro-family social policy of the American majority for a half-century, while respecting the religious convictions of all Americans. The wild ranting of his enemies is only helping him now — and may yet ruin them in November.

Joe Conason writes for Creators Syndicate. Click here for more information, or click here to contact him.

comments powered by Disqus

» on 02.16.12 @ 09:08 PM

Since when is free contraceptive drugs and abortion a right, Joe? What you fail to understand is this is going to expose the shallowness and absurdity on which the whole issue rides. No one is forced to have sex, ergo no one is forced to have contraceptive drugs and abortions, with the exception of a small number of rapes and medical problems which is less than one percent of the market.

Your liberalism has a lot riding on this. You call it reproductive rights. No one’s right to reproduce is affected Joe, only your access to free measures to prevent it when you choose to fornicate for reasons other than procreation.

» on 02.17.12 @ 11:36 AM

Well Joe, looks like you got the Media Matters memo on this topic.  Every progressive talking head in America has taken up the mantra of “this is a woman’s issue.”  It couldn’t be farther from the truth.

Organizations that are run by any church are protected under the law for a reason.  They are protected by the U.S. Constitution, which stipulates that people are free to practice the religion of their choice.  It is a protection against the very machine that is trying to shove this down their throats.  And you Joe, are complicit in this affair.

Where in the Constitution are “reproductive rights” specified?  Nowhere.

Where in the Constitution are “government provided contraceptives” specified?  Nowhere.

The fact is, any woman in any state can get free contraceptives now through any number of non-profit organizations providing free reproductive care services, to include abortion.  Why is it so important that the federal government enter the fray and impose this draconian rule?  Because it’s about power.  With progressives, it’s always about power and never about the issue.

Support Noozhawk Today

You are an important ally in our mission to deliver clear, objective, high-quality professional news reporting for Santa Barbara, Goleta and the rest of Santa Barbara County. Join the Hawks Club today to help keep Noozhawk soaring.

We offer four membership levels: $5 a month, $10 a month, $25 a month or $1 a week. Payments can be made through PayPal below, or click here for information on recurring credit-card payments.

Thank you for your vital support.


Daily Noozhawk

Subscribe to Noozhawk's A.M. Report, our free e-Bulletin sent out every day at 4:15 a.m. with Noozhawk's top stories, hand-picked by the editors.