Tuesday, December 1 , 2015, 1:14 pm | Fair 68º

Santa Barbara County Leaders Implored to Stop ‘Revolving Door’ of Mentally Ill Into Jail

Recent reports indicate that it costs much more to imprison those with mental-health problems than to treat them

Deborah McRoberts speaks during a news conference held Tuesday by Families ACT! to call for more support services for the mentally ill in Santa Barbara County. The group just published a report it believes can help with the “revolving door” between the mentally ill and the Santa Barbara County jail system.
Deborah McRoberts speaks during a news conference held Tuesday by Families ACT! to call for more support services for the mentally ill in Santa Barbara County. The group just published a report it believes can help with the “revolving door” between the mentally ill and the Santa Barbara County jail system.  (Lara Cooper / Noozhawk photo)

By Lara Cooper, Noozhawk Staff Writer | @laraanncooper |

Dozens of supporters gathered outside the county administration building in Santa Barbara on Tuesday with one message for the Board of Supervisors meeting several floors above: Stop the revolving door of the mentally ill into Santa Barbara County’s jails.

“We’re ready to go now; we have ideas,” said Suzanne Riordan, executive director of Families ACT!, the nonprofit group hosting the press conference.

The group focuses on supporting families of people with mental illness and substance abuse issues, and recently released an in-depth report outlining the steps it believes the county should take to address that revolving door. Scroll down to read a copy of the full report.

During their meeting Tuesday, the supervisors tackled two items related to that revolving door.

It’s an issue that has long plagued the county and overlaps multiple departments, including the Department of Alcohol, Drug and Mental Health Services, the Sheriff’s Department and the court system.

But law enforcement officials, often the de facto responders to mentally ill people in crisis, are now facing an additional challenge. An influx of state prisoners are serving their sentences in county jail because of Assembly Bill 109, the public safety realignment bill aimed at reducing overcrowding, costs and recidivism in state prisons. Under the law, more convicted criminals are allowed to serve their sentences in county jails rather than be sent to state prisons.

On top of that, the county ADMHS announced it has a $3.3 million budget gap and is unsure where the money will come from to fill it. But recently, the Board of Supervisors has shown it may be willing to take on the challenges of the county’s struggling mental-health system. 

Last month, the board discussed combining the ailing ADMHS department with the county’s Department of Public Health.

Also Tuesday, Fourth District Supervisor Joni Gray expressed frustration about why mentally ill people, including the homeless, continue to end up in jail.

“Everybody agrees it’s better to put folks into a housing element with supportive services if they are mentally ill,” Gray said to applause from those in the board room. “What can we do to move this? Everybody agrees but we’re not going anywhere.”

Numerous groups attempt to deal with the overlapping issues related to the mentally ill and incarceration, but more effort is needed to bring those groups together and focus efforts, County CEO Chandra Wallar responded

County staff authored a cost analysis stating that the cost to incarcerate a homeless person with mental illness is 25 percent higher than providing that person services such as housing and treatment.

But some at Tuesday’s meeting took issue with those numbers. Mike Foley, co-executive director of Bringing Our Community Home, said the report’s numbers for treatment were too high and the costs of incarceration too low. 

Court and attorney costs and emergency room and ambulances expenses weren’t included in any of the estimates, he said, adding, “Those all have to do with incarceration.”

Third District Supervisor Doreen Farr said the county’s report didn’t go far enough.

“We need a lot more analysis,” she said. “To me, 25 percent is a whole lot of money to be spending” to have people not be rehabilitated.

Farr recommended that the supervisors and staff read the Families ACT! report and come back with further steps.

“We need an action plan,” she said.

If a North County jail is built in the future, a portion of the space that opens up could be used to help treat the mentally ill, Fifth District Supervisor Steve Lavagnino said.

First District Supervisor Salud Carbajal called that idea “pragmatic,” adding that the best thing is not put mentally ill people in jail in the first place.

“The best thing is to try to find a way to not have our mentally ill go to jail,” he said to applause.

Earlier in the meeting, the supervisors heard from officials with Corizon, the private company in charge of inmate medical and mental health care. 

After a presentation from Leigh Anne Bradley of Corizon saying the company is doing more with less, many said they weren’t happy about the quality of health care inmates are receiving.

Nancy Speer spoke at Tuesday’s meeting, recounting her 22-year-old son’s year-long stay in jail, where he attempted suicide twice. She said her son was not given the treatment he needed, and she questioned Corizon’s processes.

A perceived lack of oversight also was raised. A private company may save costs, several speakers said, but should have an independent commission watching over complaints that surface.

The supervisors were also scheduled to hear about the impact of AB 109 on the first three months of the year, but will pick up that item at their May 8 meeting.

Noozhawk staff writer Lara Cooper can be reached at .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address). Follow Noozhawk on Twitter: @noozhawk, @NoozhawkNews and @NoozhawkBiz. Connect with Noozhawk on Facebook.

Families ACT! Report- In Search of Solutions to Santa Barbara’s Revolving Door Final Edit

comments powered by Disqus

» on 04.18.12 @ 04:19 AM

I have assaulted a number of friends and family members, spent ten days in the hospital, and continue to struggle with alcoholism and bi-polar disorder.
Yet every time I have gone to County Health to try to get help, they basically tell me, “You’re not crazy enough.”
It seems a person can’t get help for his mental problems until he seriously hurts someone.
It is a sad state of affairs.

Kudos to these people for taking a stand!!!

» on 04.18.12 @ 04:28 AM

Word of advice: if you are ever arrested, DO NOT tell them that you have been, or are currently suicidal.
I was once arrested when I was drunk, and I jokingly told the officers that I was suicidal. The officers knew I was joking, but the psychologist apparently thought that the best thing to do was to lock me in a drafty room by myself with no food or water for fourteen hours.
Now who would NOT be suicidal after such an experience?
The worst thing about solitary confinement is not knowing if/when it will ever end.  Everyone should experience the trauma of solitary confinement once in their life, if only so they understand why so many people go crazy after spending time behind bars.

» on 04.18.12 @ 10:57 AM

Families Act did outstanding work in organizing this news conference, and has consistently focused our community’s eyes on the needs of those who have mental health challenges, “self-medicate” with various substances and because of this loose their housing.

Elsewhere I have referred to this as the “triple challenge” of mental illness, addiction and homelessness, and some estimate that it may account for up to 25% of those who are on the street (Wayne Mellinger, Noozhawk ““Triple Challenged Can’t Grapple With Their Demons Alone” 1-14-12).

These people need integrated addiction treatment and mental health services.  The County of Santa Barbara sadly lacks these services and one of the great merits of Suzanne Riordan and Families Act is that it has consistently raised awareness for the need for rehabilitation beds.

As one who has struggled with these issues myself, and knows personally what it is like to desperately need services and to not find them, I urge the people of Santa Barbara county to contact their supervisors and let them know that you support the rights of those with mental health challenges and support their access to the supportive services they need to transition into lives of self-sufficiency. 

Let the leaders of Santa Barbara know that all human beings deserve to be treated with dignity and respect and have access to basic human services.  Let them know that you support social justice!

Wayne M. Mellinger

Community Organizer, SEAT At The Table (a new Homeless Advocacy Organization in Santa Barbara)

» on 04.18.12 @ 02:41 PM

I agree with you Schifter; just like, who wouldn’t be crazy AFTER having spent time in a mental institution?
The approach is all wrong. Someone who has been through it needs to be the adviser of those who are treating people who are going through it. Unfortunately I’m not that optimistic.
It IS for sure a sad state of affairs.

Support Noozhawk Today

You are an important ally in our mission to deliver clear, objective, high-quality professional news reporting for Santa Barbara, Goleta and the rest of Santa Barbara County. Join the Hawks Club today to help keep Noozhawk soaring.

We offer four membership levels: $5 a month, $10 a month, $25 a month or $1 a week. Payments can be made through PayPal below, or click here for information on recurring credit-card payments.

Thank you for your vital support.


Daily Noozhawk

Subscribe to Noozhawk's A.M. Report, our free e-Bulletin sent out every day at 4:15 a.m. with Noozhawk's top stories, hand-picked by the editors.