Monday, May 30 , 2016, 7:32 am | Overcast 58º

Psychologist Says Shumey Sane When He Killed Mother

By Patrick S. Pemberton, San Luis Obispo County Tribune |

A San Luis Obispo man was living in a fantasy world, but he wasn’t delusional when he gunned down his mother, who was a Lompoc Valley schoolteacher, a psychiatric witness testified for the prosecution Tuesday.

Based on his review of the evidence and more than three hours he spent with the defendant, forensic psychologist Kris Mohandie told a San Luis Obispo County Superior Court jury that Christopher Shumey was not legally insane when he murdered Karen Shumey, 65, of Arroyo Grande, on Sept. 17, 2011.

“It was overwhelmingly clear that he knew what he was doing,” Mohandie said.

Shumey has already been convicted of second-degree murder in the death of his mother, who taught at Vandenberg Middle School. The second trial now being conducted is to determine his sanity at the time of the slaying.

Defense witnesses previously noted that Shumey has had a mental illness since 1999, when he was a senior at UC Santa Cruz. But Mohandie said Shumey has exaggerated his symptoms in order to get a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity.

“I’m not saying he doesn’t have a mental illness,” Mohandie said. “What I’m saying is he’s grossly exaggerating how that impacted him at the time.”

Mohandie recently testified in three other local insanity murder cases.

He testified that John Woody, who stabbed a stranger to death at a Paso Robles Laundromat, and Kenneth Cockrell, who killed his wife with a hammer, were both sane at the time of their crimes.

In the trial of Andrew Downs, who murdered two women in Santa Margarita, he concluded the defendant was legally insane.

During his interview with Shumey, he said, the defendant acted as if he was hearing voices, but he thinks Shumey was faking.

“To me, it didn’t seem like he was having auditory hallucinations,” he said. “It seemed like it was rather theatrical.”

Shumey’s demeanor changed, he said, whenever he turned a video camera off. And his symptoms seemed to subside once their interview was over.

Defense attorney Pierre Blahnik said that in the 15 years since Shumey has been diagnosed as mentally ill, Mohandie is the only expert to suggest he was malingering, the psychiatric term for exaggerating or faking symptoms.

And previous defense witnesses testified that Shumey has experienced hallucinations in the past and kept a composition book in which he wrote to celebrities and people he’d made up.

While Blahnik has said that Shumey suffered from delusions when he shot his mother, Mohandie said Shumey had an active fantasy life, which didn’t meet the standard for delusions.

Furthermore, his actions on the day of the shooting suggest Shumey knew what he was doing.

Telling police he knew he’d killed his mother, Shumey recognized what he did and knew it was wrong, Mohandie said. Later, he expressed shame when he said he didn’t deserve to eat.

While others have diagnosed Shumey with schizoaffective disorder, Mohandie thinks he was bipolar with depression at the time. On the day of the murder, he said, Shumey wanted to kill himself but was interrupted by his mother’s visit.

“The desire to kill himself became a homicidal impulse,” he said. “He was angry at her for interfering with his suicidal plan.”

Patrick S. Pemberton is a reporter for the San Luis Obispo County Tribune. Contact him at .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address).

Reader Comments

Noozhawk's intent is not to limit the discussion of our stories but to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and must be free of profanity and abusive language and attacks.

By posting on Noozhawk, you:

» Agree to be respectful. Noozhawk encourages intelligent and impassioned discussion and debate, but now has a zero-tolerance policy for those who cannot express their opinions in a civil manner.

» Agree not to use Noozhawk’s forums for personal attacks. This includes any sort of personal attack — including, but not limited to, the people in our stories, the journalists who create these stories, fellow readers who comment on our stories, or anyone else in our community.

» Agree not to post on Noozhawk any comments that can be construed as libelous, defamatory, obscene, profane, vulgar, harmful, threatening, tortious, harassing, abusive, hateful, sexist, racially or ethnically objectionable, or that are invasive of another’s privacy.

» Agree not to post in a manner than emulates, purports or pretends to be someone else. Under no circumstances are readers posting to Noozhawk to knowingly use the name or identity of another person, whether that is another reader on this site, a public figure, celebrity, elected official or fictitious character. This also means readers will not knowingly give out any personal information of other members of these forums.

» Agree not to solicit others. You agree you will not use Noozhawk’s forums to solicit and/or advertise for personal blogs and websites, without Noozhawk’s express written approval.

Noozhawk’s management and editors, in our sole discretion, retain the right to remove individual posts or to revoke the access privileges of anyone who we believe has violated any of these terms or any other term of this agreement; however, we are under no obligation to do so.

Support Noozhawk Today

You are an important ally in our mission to deliver clear, objective, high-quality professional news reporting for Santa Barbara, Goleta and the rest of Santa Barbara County. Join the Hawks Club today to help keep Noozhawk soaring.

We offer four membership levels: $5 a month, $10 a month, $25 a month or $1 a week. Payments can be made through PayPal below, or click here for information on recurring credit-card payments.

Thank you for your vital support.


Daily Noozhawk

Subscribe to Noozhawk's A.M. Report, our free e-Bulletin sent out every day at 4:15 a.m. with Noozhawk's top stories, hand-picked by the editors.