- Home
- News Grid
- Local News
- Green Hawk
- Business
- Politics
- School Zone
- Nonprofits
- Missing Pets
- Multimedia
- Arts
- Movies
- Outdoors
- Sports
- News Releases
- Columnists
- Blogs
- Opinions
- Classifieds
- Advertise
- Donate
- Partners
Kids Speaking Up: Do Americans Still Have Values?
The strong American belief in “get-rich-quickism” has been around for centuries. America has long been known as a land of opportunity, in which anything is possible. Overall, we work hard and prosper with a fair government and an incredibly high quality of life. But does this personal-wealth attaining motto have consequences beyond economic?
At the turn of his century, President Thomas Jefferson saw the ideal American as a rugged individual, an image that was established a century earlier as the first settlers crossed the ocean to start a new life, often for economic gain (like planting cash crops/exploiting natural resources). This founded an individualistic spirit that today, combined with the materialistic and money-grabbing tendencies that still reign, have led to a saddening scantiness of community and selflessness, as well as an ironic lack of moral guidance (from a country that prides itself on being a generous and caring example for the rest of the world).
Americans are not devoid of values — indeed, we frequently hear about heroic Americans who sacrifice their lives for others, or dedicate time to community service — but these values are learned from parents and their own family tradition, rather than from America. The spirit of America, although noble in many aspects, has been and is continuing to be dominated by greed rather than compassion.
We work, we eat, we shop, we shop on sale, we buy things we can’t afford and get billed for them later (when we still can’t afford them — think 1929 and 2008), and the result is a consumerism that comes not only
in excess, but also an each-for-him/herself fashion that breeds irresponsibility.
This has been especially true during the past 60 years, as the patriotic thing to do has been to shop (remember President George W. Bush’s instructions to spend more money in order to help the economy. Any accountability that might have been present in America’s values has been smothered. Americans have been let loose on shopping malls across our great land, and the impulsive immaturity that ensues has had no American tradition of rationality or reflection to withstand it, because no such tradition is present.
Compassion and responsibility. As a country we performed only marginally. We have successes like the Marshall Plan and the Constitution, yet also a mass of failures like the Spanish-American War and Bush’s 2004 re-election in which our shortsighted jump to action and overwhelming readiness to accept empty promises led us astray.
On a personal level, however, when it comes to the values America promotes in its citizens, we have done far worse. The spirit of our country is not one of which to be proud; it is rooted in self-serving motivation and thus leaves Americans without a moral compass. We have amazing citizens, but their goodness comes not from the undercurrents of America, but from their own personal lives.
The manifestation of this in our culture is subtle, but reflects the isolated, gluttonous nature of us throughout history. A few examples: health care is not universal; much of what we buy is made in sweatshops overseas; pharmaceutical companies are allowed to inflate the price of essential medicines for profit; and some current governors are not accepting federal funding from the stimulus package for education “on
principle.”
The willingness of Americans to turn a blind eye to the aforementioned problems suggests a disparity between what America the nation preaches to the world, and what America’s spirit truly is. America the country hastily tries to rid the world of dictators and oppressors because that’s what America stands for, while America as it appears in its people quietly neglects injustices for scores and scores because the direct and personal impact is not there. It doesn’t threaten us and it doesn’t concern us — in the short run.
For too long, there has existed this blatant flaw in the base of our nation. Now more than ever — in my lifetime, certainly — there is a need for thoughtfulness and kindness in the decisions made by Americans every day. It is time for us all to close our wallets and open our hearts.
— Dos Pueblos High senior Isabelle D’Arcy is co-founder of Kids Speaking Up, a local group working to educate youth on social, national and political issues and inspire them to write.
Comments
Noozhawk's comments are moderated, but by posting here you accept your responsibility to follow our rules as part of Noozhawk's shared online community. Please keep your comments civil and helpful. Don't attack other readers personally, and do not use vulgar, abusive or discriminatory language. Use the "Report Abuse" link if a comment violates these standards or our Terms of Use.
» on 04.16.09 @ 04:54 AM
There is a clear lack of understanding that will, unfortunately, only come with years of further learning and watching of the world around you. While you are quick to point out what you see as the culprits (big pharmaceuticals, big anything, etc) you miss the other items that have grown up in our country and become corrupted to the point of doing far more harm than good. Unions are one of the largest of these.
Unions were setup to provide decent wages and safe working conditions for factory workers who were being exploited. this was a great idea. It is sad how far that has come. Teachers unions are one of the biggest detriments to public education. Tenure alone makes it nearly impossible to remove a teacher that is under preforming. Or Auto worker unions; ~$2000 of the price of every American car goes to pay for the health care costs of auto employees.
Well written, but it will only take time and working a job to support yourself for a while to let you see it from the other side.
You don't have permission to flag this entry.
» on 04.16.09 @ 06:24 PM
Dear Isabelle,
What a world, when our children are able to articulate a truth from which adults self-indulgently hide and arrogantly refuse to see.
It was a child, after all, who declared “The Emperor has no clothes!”
“Well written, but…” begins his comments with a critical judgment of your work that is unsubstantiated. Your words are spot on. We, the People, have lost our communal vision, and our community.
I am surprised that larger issues—-the genocide of Native Americans, the enslavement of Afro-Americans, the subjugation of women and abuse of children—-are not mentioned.
“Well written, but…,” named the culprit: corruption.
Please visit sbschooltalk.ning.com and mobilize your generation to expose school corruption, reform education, and restore justice and democracy in our schools and society.
Yes, you can. Thank you for speaking up!
.(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)
You don't have permission to flag this entry.
» on 04.17.09 @ 08:47 AM
You should not be demonizing individualism, because the opposite is complete dependence (on others, on government) , which stifles freedom is exactly what a tyranny and dictatorship is all about. Just because someone takes personal responsibility and tries to make and enjoy a prosperous living does not mean they are selfish and greedy. They pay taxes, they donate to charities. If everyone is poor there is nobody to take care of the poor. This is seen in countries without freedom where oppression and exploitation of the masses. I suggest you read “Animal Farm” by George Orwell to get the picture of what can happen without individualism, and has in fact happened in Communist Countries where individualism is not allowed..
You don't have permission to flag this entry.
» on 04.20.09 @ 07:44 AM
This is a beautiful, articulate, intellengent and AMAZING article. Congratulations and great job !!
You don't have permission to flag this entry.
» on 09.18.09 @ 02:33 PM
Individuality = Freedom. When will you learn? Stop believing the nonsense of the Left. When the government has control they mess things up and totally dominate your life. Americans love our personal freedom. Maybe if you were an adult who had to pay for your own “stuff” you would understand that.
You don't have permission to flag this entry.
More Local News »
Kids Speaking Up: Project Real Nostalgia
On the eve of a new decade, there's no better time to commit to making memories we can be proud of
Kids Speaking Up: Welcome to the 21st Century, Mr. Gingrich
The former House speaker's view of the world is outdated and rooted in ignorance
Kids Speaking Up Recognized for Writing
Six Dos Pueblos High students — and Noozhawk contributors — earn awards in 2009 California Press Women High School Journalism Contest
Kids Speaking Up: Bottled Water Is Just ... Water
A drink from the tap is just as healthy and a fraction of the cost
Kids Speaking Up: The Floatopian Disaster
Residents beware as a horde of college students descends on Del Playa this weekend
Weather: Fair 54.0º
Search Noozhawk »
