Jordan Takes Lead Role in Stand Against Carpinteria Slant-Drilling Operation

Venoco's Paredon project runs into opponents citing a flurry of concerns about open space, safety and process

By | Published on 03.07.2010

  • E-mail
  • Print this page Print
  • Post | View Comments (21)
  • Share
 

Walking a trail along the Carpinteria Bluffs probably best illustrates Donna Jordan’s apprehension with Venoco Inc.‘s Paredon project.

If Carpinteria voters approve the oil company’s slant-drilling initiative in a June special election, the operation will originate from Venoco’s Dump Road property.

Former Carpinteria Mayor Donna Jordan is leading the fight against Venoco Inc.'s proposed slant-drilling operation, which would originate at the oil company's Dump Road facility behind her.
Former Carpinteria Mayor Donna Jordan is leading the fight against Venoco Inc.‘s proposed slant-drilling operation, which would originate at the oil company’s Dump Road facility behind her. (Lara Cooper / Noozhawk photo)

Extended-reach, or slant, drilling would allow access to oil and natural gas in the Santa Barbara Channel without using an offshore platform, and could reach up to 11,000 barrels of oil a day.

But Jordan, one of the key organizers opposing the project, is quick to cite multiple reasons why the project shouldn’t go forward.

“It’s not so much what it is, but where it is,” said Jordan, referring to the 52-acre bluffs parcel of open space that abuts the Venoco property.

The bluffs were designated as open space more than a decade ago, when Jordan and a slew of other citizens came up with about $4 million to purchase the property from a developer, who had planned hundreds of condominiums and a shopping mall for the site. At the base of the bluffs is a seal rookery, where five months out of the year seals come to bear their young. The mammals co-exist with Venoco’s pier, which is used for oil and gas transportation.

Adjoining another side of the Venoco property are condos and senior mobile homes that lie downwind of where the new project would be located, which is another concern of Jordan, a former Carpinteria mayor and councilwoman.

Last week, Noozhawk sat down with Venoco’s Lisa Rivas to hear the company’s presentation of the project and the citizens’ initiative — the Paredon Oil and Gas Development Initiative — on the June 8 ballot. Click here for the article.

Standing on the other side of the issue are residents who have mobilized with Jordan as a part of the group, Citizens Against Paredon.

Various representatives of the group, including Jordan, have shown up at City Council meetings to rail against the project, in front of a council that, for the most part, shares their views. The majority of the council has taken issue with the Paredon project’s route, saying the citizens’ initiative circumvents the environmental review process.

Carpinteria’s General Plan doesn’t have provisions for slant drilling at an onshore location, and more than 1,000 signatures were gathered to put Paredon, now known as Measure J, before voters in the community of 14,000.

But because ballot initiatives like Paredon aren’t subject to the California Environmental Quality Act before they are passed, Jordan and others wonder how accountable Venoco will be on the other side of the ballot box.

Venoco officials have said the project will still be subject to oversight agencies like the Santa Barbara County Air Pollution Control District if it’s approved.

But that response doesn’t bring any comfort to Jordan.

“These agencies are remote, narrowly focused and rarely do anything on site,” she said.

Venoco purchased the Dump Road facility from Chevron in 1999. Chevron had acquired permits for the site in the 1950s and the facility was there before the city of Carpinteria incorporated in 1965.

“It’s still a 50 year old plant,” Jordan said. “They bought this plant, and they knew it wasn’t zoned for drilling.”

Jordan said that when Venoco first came forward with the project, she was open-minded about it.

“I’m not an automatic anti-oil person,” she said, acknowledging that oil is an essential part of South Coast energy use.

But it wasn’t until Venoco was well into the environmental review process, Jordan said, that she started to get concerned with the project.

Jordan maintains that the initiative would change the General Plan, exempting only Venoco and forcing the city to issue permits — “except they can’t issue them the normal way,” she said.

The initiative says that if any part of Venoco’s specific plan is inconsistent with the city’s code or regulations, the plan takes precedence. It goes even further to say that if official policies of the city “frustrate” the company’s purpose, the specific plan of the company has the authority to move forward.

“It ties the city’s hands,” Jordan said of the provision. “What they would do is an open-ended question.”

Safety concerns come up often when Jordan talks about the Paredon project. The Carpinteria-Summerland Fire Department would have jurisdiction over the project if it is approved, and Jordan says that agency isn’t as well equipped for oversight of oil and gas plants as Santa Barbara County teams, which regularly audit the plants for safety.

“If Venoco had completed the city’s review process ... they would surely have come under the jurisdiction of county HazMat (Santa Barbara County Fire Department hazardous materials response) because the city would have contracted with them like Goleta does,” she said.

“The Carp Fire Department has no such expertise and lacks the resources to really develop a similar team. This is worrisome, to say the least.”

If voters approve Venoco’s proposal, company representatives say Carpinteria and the county would be entitled to royalties and revenue of as much as $200 million. Venoco has also said 20 acres of coastal land would be donated to the city as open space, and $5 million will be donated to the Carpinteria Education Foundation.

But revenue sharing with local governments from new development on existing tideland leases is part of a bill that expired in 2007, and Jordan said she feels the city can’t count on this revenue.

Jordan said she’s been taken aback by all the volunteers willing to join the effort against the project. More than 85 people showed up recently to walk precincts door to door, talking about the project.

The group put also put out door hangers, which had tear-away cards that people could mail in with their responses to the project.

“People were writing and responding ‘never in our town,’” she said. “I didn’t expect that kind of reaction. For some time, people have been complacent. This has stirred them up.”

Jordan estimates about 200 people are involved in the effort now, and they have a table at the Carpinteria farmers market each Thursday to pass out literature.

Representatives from both Venoco and Citizens Against Paredon have one thing in common, however, and that’s that they’re both encouraging Carpinterians to read the entire initiative before making a decision. Click here the read the initiative.

And as for the June 8 election?

“I have confidence in the voters to do the right thing,” Jordan said.

Noozhawk staff writer Lara Cooper can be reached at .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address).

Comments

Noozhawk's comments are moderated, but by posting here you accept your responsibility to follow our rules as part of Noozhawk's shared online community. Please keep your comments civil and helpful. Don't attack other readers personally, and do not use vulgar, abusive or discriminatory language. Use the "Report Abuse" link if a comment violates these standards or our Terms of Use.

You must be a registered user to comment. Create a user account

Log in




Auto-login on future visits

Forgot your password?

» on 03.08.10 @ 04:45 AM

“Jordan said she feels the city can’t count on this revenue.”  Then structure the agreement so that you can.  Daniel Petry

You don't have permission to flag this entry.

» on 03.08.10 @ 07:49 AM

The NIMBYS are at it once again. It does not matter if it is an oil facility, a foot bridge replacing a dangerous old bridge over a local creek, widening a freeway overpass..etc. ANY change is bad for them.  It is hard to imagine a more reasonable project. What a great compromise.  Instead of drilling in the middle of the ocean, lets slant drill for it on land in the middle of an existing industrial complex, a long ways from homes, surrounded by 150 foot tall eucalyptus trees. We have oil, everyone of these NIMBYS drive cars and wear rubber soled shoes and they NEED oil for their daily lives. 
** If you are concerned with the specifics of the proposal, then lets have the city council take a leadership and visionary role to craft something that is real powerful, positively focused and can make something great out of this proposal for the community.

You don't have permission to flag this entry.

» on 03.08.10 @ 08:21 AM

Good for you, Donna.  Just keep shipping our money to the middle East.  Right.  That’s the ticket.  Party like it’s 1969.

You don't have permission to flag this entry.

» on 03.08.10 @ 09:03 AM

John and John,
You took the words right out of what I wanted to write!  That footbridge is beautiful.  Where was their concern for the condos and mobile homes while fighting a third lane.  Driving to work this morning, stop and go traffic again spewing the exhaust that direction.  We are all downwind from the biggest polluter to our air and beaches…...natural seep pollution.  Beautiful bumper stickers they have, though…...on the back of their gas powered automobiles!

You don't have permission to flag this entry.

» on 03.08.10 @ 09:58 AM

When I see these people living in a tee pee constructed of naturally grown fibers grown on their own land, wearing clothing that is naturally grown and made, from their own land and eating food they grew on their own land, all done with their own labor and not depending on anything that comes from oil, fuel, fiber, food, medicine, anything, then I’ll give their rants some credence. Until then keep smoking crack you raging NIMBY hypocrites.
What this whole affair makes painfully obvious is the utter lack of comprehension most Americans have at what it takes for our entire society to function. If it weren’t for oil most of us would not be alive today and those that are would be living a very much harsher life. It used to be that people were very connected to the means that supported them. Not anymore. China, the OPEC and Japan support us now on borrowed money. When you NIMBYs are starving to death you might want to look back on your little adventure in La La Land and remember what grandpa used to tell you about paying for what you wanted.

You don't have permission to flag this entry.

» on 03.08.10 @ 10:40 AM

Jordan is a union puppet and she is Padro’s wife—Now she thinks she is entitled to the high paying government.

Tax and spend nut—Bad for you and I

No thank you—Go Mike stoker—

You don't have permission to flag this entry.

» on 03.08.10 @ 11:22 AM

In response to John Locke: According to the Energy Information Administration, in 2008 the United States consumed 19.5 million barrels of oil PER DAY.  According to an estimate supplied by Venoco, they anticipate that the Paredon field COULD produce 13.6 million barrels of oil OVER ITS 20-30 YEAR LIFE, which is less than one day’s worth of oil at today’s daily rate of consumption.  So even if Measure J passes we will continue to ship our money to the Saudi’s.
Measure J is a complex issue that should not be reduced to platitutes and sound bites.  If passed its impacts will have a duration of 20 to 30 years.  And its impact on either the price and supply of oil and gas are beyond insignificant.  It’s like throwing a pebble in the ocean and expecting a tidal wave.

You don't have permission to flag this entry.

» on 03.08.10 @ 12:12 PM

AN50 - “It used to be that people were very connected to the means that supported them. Not anymore.” you are right on target.  These people remind me of the Eloi of H.G. Wells story.  Clueless, living off the work of the out of sight Morlocks.  Letting the hard work and knowledge of centruies go to dust.  A pampered, spoiled, ignorant species.  Only in this case Jordon is not being bred for food.  Instead, Carpinteria loses out from resource development.  But you listen to the same people as gas goes past $5 per gallon.

You don't have permission to flag this entry.

» on 03.08.10 @ 12:33 PM

Yea Bob, that ripple is $200,000,000 in royalties over 20 years.  God you people love to obfuscate.  Your economic ignorance used to be quaint now it is actually killing our nation.

You don't have permission to flag this entry.

» on 03.08.10 @ 02:19 PM

To Charlene:  As “obfuscate” means “to confuse”, I hope I didn’t confuse anybody by simply assembling a senario based on a stated set of facts, including sources.
As to your assertion of $200,000,000 (in oil and gas royalties), now that’s obfuscation.  Even Venoco hedges on that claim, qualifying it by adding “up to”.  The fact is that nobody knows exactly how much oil is out there and all Venoco or anyone else can do is to create models based on a set of assumptions.  Venoco has created three different models based on three different sets of assumptions.  Their estimates of local royalties, to be divided between the City of Carpinteria and the County of Santa Barbara range from $14,000,000 to $200,000,000.  What’s the difference?  According to Venoco there’s a 90% probability of $14 mil in royalty payments, but only a 10% probability of $200 mil.  So to assert that $200 mil in royalty payments will be realized is more wishful thinking that fact.  In reality we’re talking about carving up a pie that hasn’t even been mixed and baked.  If insufficient amounts of oil and gas are found, there will be no pie. 
I know my position is in the minority here, but will some of you please take this discussion beyond tea party talking points and stereotyping.

You don't have permission to flag this entry.

» on 03.08.10 @ 03:18 PM

Bob, obfuscate can also mean muddy up the water so the real issue is hidden.  I don’t think anyone is stereotyping here.  But when you use the term Tea Party you think you are pushing the conversation away from an area you have trouble defending and also placing a brand on those that disagree with you.  It doesn’t.  These are concerned citizens that realize that the path you want us to take…in fact a path that you have had us take for decades, is the wrong way.

Now it is my personal belief, that the economic paradigm is changing and it’s not changing in the direction you want Bob.

Imagine it this way.  You have a country that has more proven sources of energy than any nation on the planet.  Unfortunately this nation was able to keep its resource base fairly whole due to the fact that the planet had to use its currency and that this nations leaders grew up thinking that the cash pig and credit card buying would go on forever.  It hasn’t.  We are a debtor nation (been one for some time) that has pushed the world’s financial patience to the limit.  We are consumers addicted to consuming and ‘free’ social benefits.  We have lived far beyond our means and we can either adapt or be forced to adapt.  This is the paradigm change. 

There is no money.  There is no money for city, county, and state bonds.  There is no money for grandiose social programs.  Even if you taxed this nation’s people at 100% you would never be able to cover the credit card payments incurred over the past 70 years.  Our deficit payments are now approaching $1.2 trillion a year, (and it is the fault of all of us).

It is a pressure cooker and the pressure is building up to a degree I have never seen in my life.  When people are looking a $5++ per gallon of gas they will no longer have the patience of listening to those of you who preach that they must live without.  To think otherwise is foolish.  You will be but a smear in the road as they rush to get the fuel and products that make their lives livable.

The oil industry is so far distant from what it was even fifteen years ago.  We could argue ad nauseam about the environment but that is pointless.  So, we should negotiate the best guaranteed deal we can, pocket the cash to take care of basic services and go on our way.  Daniel Petry

You don't have permission to flag this entry.

» on 03.08.10 @ 03:24 PM

Bob, I am with you 100%. You have the same cast of characters such as Petry and AN50 taking a position that when anyone disagrees with them they must not even have a brain or work for a living. Petry is particularly out of line because he critizes the government and their employees when he worked for them and enjoys their benefits.  AN50, always has the same rant about society and working hard and that everyone who disagrees with him is socialist or some lazy homeless person.  Remember, you are dealing with folks that think global climate change is a hoax and believe we have the best health insurance system and medical deliver in the world. I hope that puts things into the proper perspective. Maybe they would allow Veneco to drill in their backyard if they are so concerned about it?

The fact is that Venoco does not want to play by the same rules and oversight that every other corporation or individual has to adhere to. They are trying to shift jurisdiction to an entity that is not capable of assessing the risk or hazard or impact. They are trying to gain a favorable decision by enticing all with revenues predictions that are blown out way out of proportion.

You don't have permission to flag this entry.

» on 03.08.10 @ 03:45 PM

Ad hominem.  No problem.  The fact still remains.  We do not have the money needed to run what is even currently on the board let alone the lovely programs planned. 

On a personal note - local, I have never used my benefits and I contribute a minimum of 10% of my gross to charity.  And I served.  Can you claim the same?  Daniel Petry

You don't have permission to flag this entry.

» on 03.08.10 @ 03:55 PM

Ok, Bob, why are you looking a gift horse in the mouth then? How about, you use the damned stuff, so therefore show a little reasonableness in its extraction. BTW – saying no all the time, as residents of the south coast have become accustom to, is not a solution. It’s just being too damned aloof to care how things get done as long as it’s nowhere near me.
People we are $50 trillion in the hole right now and we are not going to climb out of that hole in Birkenstocks. No, Pickens is wrong, wind mills will not pull us out either nor will any of the other odd ball expensive cost-more-to-produce-than-it’s-worth green energy schemes being introduced today. We need desperately to extract and produce our own energy, natural resources and make our own stuff. Dammit if people don’t start waking up to that simple reality and PDQ then there are going to be a lot of starving, shivering, out-in- the-cold babyboomers in about 20 years (yep when your old and really helpless, got it?). And long before that we are going to see a rapid deterioration in our standard of living. You libs out there and your old fart NIMBY neighbors better get a grip. Your computer will not run without oil, nor will Google’s server farm. Your food will not grow without oil unless you grow your own and as a Midas touch green thumb myself I can tell you, most of you are not skilled enough to grow your own food let alone the weeds in your yard (not that any of you who are not idle wealthy have that kind of time anyway).
So spare me the drama and trauma over this ridicules display of absolute ignorance and get a freaking clue. We need that oil to survive, let alone help pay down that horrible debt we have accumulated over the last 40 years. Is that clear enough Bob or is it just more ranting from the Tea Party mob? BTW - your mother is a tea party member so watch out how you refer to that group. I get tired of the only “real” grassroots movement being besmirched by the phony “paid grassroots” people on the left.

You don't have permission to flag this entry.

» on 03.08.10 @ 04:06 PM

To Daniel Petry:
» “AN50 on 03.08.10 @ 09:58 AM”

“When I see these people living in a tee pee constructed of naturally grown fibers grown on their own land, wearing clothing that is naturally grown and made, from their own land and eating food they grew on their own land, all done with their own labor and not depending on anything that comes from oil, fuel, fiber, food, medicine, anything, then I’ll give their rants some credence. Until then keep smoking crack you raging NIMBY hypocrites.
What this whole affair makes painfully obvious is the utter lack of comprehension most Americans have at what it takes for our entire society to function. If it weren’t for oil most of us would not be alive today and those that are would be living a very much harsher life. It used to be that people were very connected to the means that supported them. Not anymore. China, the OPEC and Japan support us now on borrowed money. When you NIMBYs are starving to death you might want to look back on your little adventure in La La Land and remember what grandpa used to tell you about paying for what you wanted”.
...If there ain’t some stereotypin’ in that rant, then I guess I don’t know what stereotypin’ is.

You don't have permission to flag this entry.

» on 03.08.10 @ 04:07 PM

Local, thanks for affirming my last rant. Without you I would not have a concrete example of how badly out of touch people are with reality. Global warming is real, anthropogenic relationship is what we doubt. Health care is the best here, if you can afford it. It sucks everywhere else, unless you are rich and we cannot afford what you want, like it or not. And yes I would give my eye teeth to have Venoco drill in my back yard because I’d be stinking rich and you would not, idiot. Dan, Charlene and I believe in the old pay-as-you-go method, Local, not the “kick all that dirty industry out of here and I’ll borrow the money for my lifestyle from the Chinese” method you and your liberal friends seem to think works so well. But I tire of your consistent lack of connection to reality. You will learn the truth and in a very painful way to you and your family. Starvation and exposure have a way of focusing your attention to what is real and what you think is real like nothing else. GET A CLUE!

You don't have permission to flag this entry.

» on 03.08.10 @ 05:19 PM

I’ll say it again - Ad hominem.  No problem.  The fact still remains.  We do not have the money needed to run what is even currently on the board let alone the lovely programs planned.

You don't have permission to flag this entry.

» on 03.08.10 @ 06:21 PM

To Petry, I am glad that you “served”. Good for you. It is a volunteer army and as far back as I was elgible I did not agree with our war policies. I think invading Iraq and the Vietnam War were wrong. They were both justified through fabricated evidence. I admire that you “served” but it does not make you better than others. The folks that fought in WW2, a justified war, now there is a different story. Now you say you never used your benefits: no help with college or taxes or the VA or ?? You may want to double check that statement. Better not take those military retirement benefits, after all that is government.

I not only donate more than 10% of my income to charities, I spend a many hours a week volunteering my time. I think contributing time and effort is more important than money.

We agree to disagree on almost every subject. That is fine. When I was much younger,I had much more conservative capitalist leanings such as yourself and AN50. I have learned that when you allow many people to operate in an unrestricted free market, unfortunately, they take advantage of it. The greed factor conquers what is the right thing to do. This is the case with Venoco. If they were sincere about doing the right thing, they would play by the rules. This is no different than what happened with the meltdown on wall street. Some do not want to play by the rules, because there is more money in pushing the envelope, risk taking ,bending or breaking the rules than playing it straight up.

You don't have permission to flag this entry.

» on 03.08.10 @ 06:24 PM

Dan, simple is best. Carpentaria, you and the American people are broke and buying more Birkenstocks will not help you. That black, gooey, smelly, flammable stuff we pull out of the ground will help you pay your bills. Plain enough Local? No stereo typing for ya Bob? I don’t know how much more simple you have to make it for these people, will they really have to starve before the bulb comes on?

You don't have permission to flag this entry.

» on 03.08.10 @ 06:36 PM

I’ll say it again - Ad hominem.  No problem.  The fact still remains.  We do not have the money needed to run what is even currently on the board let alone the lovely programs planned.  Daniel Petry

You don't have permission to flag this entry.

» on 03.09.10 @ 08:03 PM

Yes, Bob, and by your logic we should never try to solve any problem incrementally.  Really terrible argument.  Try again.

You don't have permission to flag this entry.

More Local News »

County Supervisors Approve First Reading of Oil Pipeline Agreement for Venoco

Next week's public meeting the last step before the company can begin operations

Goleta Seeks Public Input on Law Enforcement Services

Participants are needed for two focus groups scheduled for Feb. 15

City Council Authorizes Design Contract for Redevelopment of Cliff Drive Intersection

Tuesday's meeting is dedicated to Santa Barbara filmmaker Mike deGruy, who died in a helicopter crash; a memorial service is planned for Sunday

Goleta Woman Accused of Having Sex with Teen Boy

Sheriff's Department says victim recently came forward about 2008 relationship

Goleta Police Warn Public About Recent Home Burglaries

Witnesses report seeing a suspect going door to door in the neighborhood around Scripps Crescent Street

Weather: Fair 55.0º


© Malamute Ventures LLC 2007-2012 | ISSN No. 1947-6086

Web Design & Development by PixelFive