Saturday, November 28 , 2015, 7:40 am | Fair 38º

Neighborhood Clinics Issue Funding Plea to Avert Shutdown

Organization needs $1.5 million to carry it through the end of the year

Acting CEO Mark Palmer, left, and Medical Director Dr. Charles Fenzi explain the funding crisis facing the Santa Barbara Neighborhood Clinics Wednesday.
Acting CEO Mark Palmer, left, and Medical Director Dr. Charles Fenzi explain the funding crisis facing the Santa Barbara Neighborhood Clinics Wednesday.  (Lara Cooper / Noozhawk photo)

By Lara Cooper, Noozhawk Staff Writer | @laraanncooper |

Running short on cash and facing an imminent shutdown, Santa Barbara Neighborhood Clinic officials issued an urgent plea Wednesday for the community’s help in raising the money needed to cover operating costs while they work to revamp their business model by the end of the year.

“We are at risk of closing our doors today,” Acting CEO Mark Palmer told reporters gathered in a conference room at the organization’s Eastside Clinic.

The clinics, located on the Eastside and Westside of Santa Barbara, and in Isla Vista, serve as the only health-care option for many low-income people in the area. 

Last year, Santa Barbara Neighborhood Clinics served nearly 17,000 patients, 95 percent of whom were below the poverty line. 

A third of those were children, and 66 percent of the people served are Hispanic. 

In a medical landscape where primary care physicians are becoming increasingly rare, and emergency room care often becomes the only medical attention poorer residents have access to, the clinics’ mission has been treating all patients, regardless of ability to pay.

But while their mission may be noble, the clinics are in financial trouble.

A perfect storm of forces have coalesced, Palmer said, creating the current situation.

An increase in patients over the past five years, most unable to pay for services, plus a decline in community giving, which helps to fund operations, have contributed to the problem.

Larger forces also have been at work, such as the requirement to digitize medical records and other changes required for the Affordable Care Act.

“The medical landscape is changing incredibly,” he said, and the organization’s business model must change.

In order to figure out how to best do that, the organization assembled an advisory group, which included leaders from Cottage Hospital, Sansum Clinics, Santa Barbara County Public Health Department and CenCal.

Through those talks, the group has identified five areas that need to change substantially to be sustainable.

They include reimbursement rates for patients — Palmer said Neighborhood Clinics has the lowest reimbursement rates of any medical establishment locally; managing costs, private insurance, and expanding grants and community support.

As a result of those talks, Cottage Hospital agreed to pay for HFS Consultants to look into how to best craft a new business model for the organization.

The path to sustainability is there, but it will take six months to get a plan in place.

“We need time to implement,” Palmer said.

To allow for six months and remain operating during that time, the clinics need $1.5 million to cover operating costs.

That will pays for everything from doctor paychecks to keeping the lights on, and that campaign for funding begins now.

In addition to addressing their immediate needs for operating dollars, another challenge looms over the clinics.

With ACA implementation at the beginning of next year, the clinic expects to see even more patients. Though many of those people will qualify for federal and state money to pay for care, more clinicians and primary care doctors will have to be hired to deal with the demand.

Medical Director Dr. Charles Fenzi called the ACA “a mixed bag” for that reason, and added that the ACA still does nothing to cover undocumented people, who make up a large portion of the clinic’s patients.

The ACA also does not cover dental care at all, and Quynh Nguyen, DDS, was on hand to talk about what she’s seen at the quarterly dental clinics that offer free care.

People often begin forming lines outside, around the building, the night before the clinics just to be seen, she said.

Elimination of dental benefits from Medi-Cal in 2009 by the state Legislature in order to save money left many people without access to dental care, so the clinics work to see as many people as possible.

Distributing oral health kits has also been key, and it’s not unusual to see an entire family who will share a toothbrush received from the clinic, she said.

If the clinics go away, patients will end up on the emergency room more often than they do now, which is extremely costly and doesn’t provide the depth of care that a primary doctor can, Fenzi said.

“This is about community health,” he said. “We serve the people that take care of our gardens and work in our restaurants… This is a clinic where an important population comes to get health care.”

Donations may be made online at or mailed to Santa Barbara Neighborhood Clinics, 1900 State St., Suite G, Santa Barbara 93101.

For more information, please call Coleen McBride, Santa Barbara Neighborhood Clinics Development & marketing coordinator, at 805.617.7869.

Noozhawk staff writer Lara Cooper can be reached at .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address). Follow Noozhawk on Twitter: @noozhawk, @NoozhawkNews and @NoozhawkBiz. Connect with Noozhawk on Facebook.

comments powered by Disqus

» on 05.22.13 @ 08:19 PM

How many of these patients have cable tv and/or smartphones?

Many can actually afford to pay a little if not all for their care but they choose not to.  Perhaps people should sacrifice a bit more for their own well being so they understand the true costs of their life and their lifestyle???  Right…

In the meantime, give these folks the money they need.  They do a good service and do help reduce suffering.

» on 05.22.13 @ 10:26 PM

Too many from Mexico wanting more free stuff, and the lazy losers on Welfare food stamps and section 8.

» on 05.23.13 @ 11:12 AM

The question that comes to mind is, what role does the unionization of the Neighborhood Clinics personnel play in the current financial dilemma.

» on 05.23.13 @ 11:49 AM

Too bad that the question that comes to mind isn’t “How can I help my neighbors and why would these doctors work in a Neighborhood Clinic instead of in high-paying private practice?”

» on 05.23.13 @ 12:48 PM

Low cost or no cost birth-control, and classes on how to use it.  That could help too.

» on 05.23.13 @ 02:29 PM

I am a patient at Franklin Clinic. I pay at a discounted rate, not free treatment. I am a self employed, single, middle aged woman, and do not have health insurance. The clinic has been very helpful to me, I only go once every two years to get lab work and a renewal of my Thyroid medication. If I went to a private practice to do this the appointment and lab work would come close to $600.00. If the clinics go away I am sure I will find someone else to care for my health needs but not a situation that would be as understanding in terms of my finances.

» on 05.23.13 @ 05:28 PM

Cottage operates the only hospitals in the area.  It seems that it would be the single entity most impacted by the closure of The SB Neighborhood Clinics, suddenly seeing many more patients without financial means showing up at its ERs.  Unable to turn many of these emergency cases away, it could cost Cottage more over the next six months than the $1.5 million needed to keep the Clinics’ doors open for the same period of time while a plan for future operations is devised and put in place.  With an endowment of hundreds of millions, Cottage has the ability to step up with the lion’s share of the needed contribution, and it should do because it has a practical interest in avoiding the consequences of the closure.  It is best for Cottage to avoid the problems for its local hospital ERs for years to come, if they have to do without the medical resources provided by the Clinics.  It appears to be in Cottage’s economic self-interest to be public spirited in this regard.  It would be good business and good public relations, both.

» on 05.23.13 @ 08:16 PM

Ah, not to worry! ObamaCare will fill in the gaps.

» on 05.23.13 @ 09:14 PM

Frankly, I would rather continue with my current state of no health insurance than have Obamacare. There’s something about knowing Obama’s Brown Shirt enforcers, the IRS, causing me more grief than they already do that doesn’t seem worth it.

» on 05.24.13 @ 03:12 PM

Still the ONLY western industrialized nation without a national health system! Sure, ACA is a small step in the right direction, but by allowing the health insurance companies to write the legislation, “Obamacare” doesn’t go far enough in addressing the incredible inefficiencies caused by not having a single payer model. Despite what the corporate propagandists say, there ARE health care systems in many other nations that run very well, achieving both better results than the U.S. system and at a far lower cost. Watch this documentary for some examples:

» on 05.24.13 @ 06:52 PM

“The question that comes to mind is, what role does the unionization of the Neighborhood Clinics personnel play in the current financial dilemma.

These clinics are unionized? I was actually feeling sympathetic about their financial needs, but if this is true, then let them get the money from their fat-cat union coffers.

Support Noozhawk Today

You are an important ally in our mission to deliver clear, objective, high-quality professional news reporting for Santa Barbara, Goleta and the rest of Santa Barbara County. Join the Hawks Club today to help keep Noozhawk soaring.

We offer four membership levels: $5 a month, $10 a month, $25 a month or $1 a week. Payments can be made through PayPal below, or click here for information on recurring credit-card payments.

Thank you for your vital support.


Daily Noozhawk

Subscribe to Noozhawk's A.M. Report, our free e-Bulletin sent out every day at 4:15 a.m. with Noozhawk's top stories, hand-picked by the editors.