David Sirota: Intelligentsia Against Intelligence

Professional thinkers calling on the president to avoid taking time to think through his actions is a disturbing trend

By | Published on 11.23.2009

  • E-mail
  • Print this page Print
  • Comments (17)
  • Share

In the parlance of our times, the term “idiocracy” means a nation run by idiots — and the term “idiot” is defined by the dictionary as “an utterly foolish or senseless person” who exhibits “a mental age of less than 3 years old.”

David Sirota
David Sirota

There are obvious reasons to believe America is becoming an idiocracy. A series of horrendous government and business decisions strongly suggest that we’ve seen the ascension of utterly foolish, senseless people, many with the mental age of infants (yes, W., I’m looking at you). And if there remained any flicker of hope that we aren’t turning into a full-on slobbering idiocracy, that hope was snuffed out recently by two of the Washington intelligentsia’s most respected voices.

First came a now-famous column about Afghanistan by the Washington Post’s David Broder. The “dean” of the press corps attacked President Barack Obama not for choosing any particular policy, but for simply taking time to meticulously consider his options in the Central Asian quagmire. “The urgent necessity,” Broder asserted, “is to make a decision — whether or not it is right.”

This was followed by Jackson Diehl, the Post’s foreign policy “expert.” He wrote that the White House’s assiduous Afghanistan deliberations are not a sign of reassuring prudence after the bring-it-on Bush years, but instead a “compelling cause for unease about this president.” Diehl’s rationale for such an incendiary statement? He alleged (without proof, of course) that “there is unanimity in the Pentagon and considerable agreement in Congress and among the NATO allies” that a military escalation has to happen — and therefore Obama “knows (the pro-escalation) course he must take” but “can’t bring himself to embrace it.”

Let’s set aside the nauseating spectacle of two well-heeled journalists, comfortably protected far away from the front lines, demanding a president immediately send thousands of soldiers to their potential deaths without regard for blood-and-guts consequences. Let’s just, if we can, put that grotesque immorality in a corner and pretend it’s not important — and let’s go to the deeper, even more disturbing message.

As leading opinion-makers, Broder and Diehl are paid to carefully ponder issues and then offer their considered thoughts. That’s not part of what they’re supposed to do — it’s what they are singularly employed to do. It’s how they earn their living and credibility — indeed, it’s their entire raison d’etre. And yet, these leading lights of the intelligentsia are overtly preaching anti-intelligence, insisting the president must avoid taking time to think through his actions.

This isn’t interpretation — it’s what these Beltway sages are literally saying. Broder is explicitly demanding Obama make a knee-jerk decision — any decision — even if it has catastrophic consequences. Likewise, Diehl is calling for Obama to immediately risk thousands of American lives simply because that’s what Diehl believes the establishment wants.

Let’s be clear: These are just two of many similar examples. Today, screeds calling for leaders to prioritize lightning-fast decisions over measured deliberations are increasingly commonplace in the Washington intelligentsia, even after an Iraq debacle brought on by the same ideological know-nothingism.

The trend is deeply disturbing. It’s one thing for talk-show-host wannabe Sarah Palin or carnival-barking provocateur Glenn Beck to glamorize willful ignorance — that’s been the narcissistic act of celebrity court jesters since the dawn of history. But it’s an entirely different thing when hostility to intelligence and to the basic process of thinking itself emanates from the very professional thinkers who lead the nation’s intelligentsia.

When that happens — when the supposed guardians of political cognition and empiricism begin publicly flaying leaders for taking time to fully evaluate potential decisions — it’s a sign our country is becoming the ignorance-deifying idiocracy we should all fear.

David Sirota is the author of the best-selling books Hostile Takeover and The Uprising. He hosts the morning show on AM 760 in Colorado and blogs at OpenLeft.com. Click here for more information. He can be contacted at .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address).

Comments

Noozhawk's comments are moderated, but by posting here you accept your responsibility to follow our rules.

  1. No abusive, defamatory or libelous attacks. In plain English: No personal attacks.
  2. No vulgar or discriminatory language.
  3. If you do not follow these rules, don't be surprised if your comment is removed.
  4. Please use the Report Abuse button on offensive comments.
  5. Share what you know, ask about what you don't. Give us your eyewitness accounts, observations, background and history. Tell us what else you want to know about the story.
  6. Stay on the topic, PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK, and forgive people their spelling errors.

Noozhawk's intent is not to limit the discussion of our stories but to elevate it. Thank you for your respectful participation. Click here for our complete Terms of Use.

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until they've been approved.

You must be a registered user to comment. Create a user account

Log in




Auto-login on future visits

Forgot your password?

» on 11.23.09 @ 07:44 PM

Obama is a big clumsy puppet of the Communist Socialist left in this country and he doesn’t even realize it. Someday he will wake up and realize he’s a naive idealogue who is being used.


» on 11.23.09 @ 10:55 PM

my two cents is worth just that. I am sure that my two cents has no idea what communism and socialism are. The first piece of evidence of their ignorance is to put the two terms together when they are completely different forms of government. My two cents was probably a big fan of our past Corporate Fascist President that nearly brought our country to its knees through greed,cronism, incompetence and deregulation.

Great article. What do you expect from a nation of people with a high school graduation rate under 70% and an attention spand of a goldfish?


» on 11.24.09 @ 04:42 AM

local you’re so ignorant it’s funny. Are you one of the high school dropouts you speak of? Because you forgot to learn how to spell. You also must have missed social studies and civics. Your political knowledge is based on parroting something you heard somewhere but didn’t put much thought or research into. Allow me to educate you.

I do happen to know what the terms mean and they are not mutually exclusive.  In fact, one is a transition to the other. Neither are “forms of government” but rather, theories or forms of social organization. Capitalism is not a form of government either.

SOCIALISM is (in Marxist theory) the stage following capitalism in the transition of a society to communism.

COMMUNISM is a theory or system of social organization based on the holding of all property in common, actual ownership being ascribed to the community as a whole or to the state.You can be a socialist AND a communist if you believe in Marxism, if you think that is the way things should be.

“cronism” (spelled cronyism) is the practice of favoring one’s close friends, esp. in political appointments.

One kind of greed and “cronism” has simply been replaced with another and corporate greed has been replaced with government handout greed and entitlement greed.

You don’t think Obama has appointed any of his friends as “czars” or cabinet members?? You’re ignorant.

You think Bush was a Fascist? I don’t think you know what that means either but it sounds like a really big mean word that you heard somewhere so you use it in your obsessive irrational Bush hatred.

Fascism IS a governmental system led by a dictator having complete power, forcibly suppressing opposition and criticism, regimenting all industry, commerce, etc., and emphasizing an aggressive nationalism and often racism.

No I was not a fan of our past President because he was too liberal, but he was far from a fascist.  Bush never had complete power, did not forcibly try to suppress opposition and criticism, believed in the private sector as opposed to regimenting industry (you yourself said he was into deregulation - the very opposite of regimenting) and did not try aggressively to nationalize anything. GM maybe, I don’t know how “aggressive” he was and I don’t know how much credit to give to congress. If he did, I sure was not a fan of that, and Obama continued it and was a lot more aggressive.

If you want to see a fascist open your eyes and look at what Obama and the Democrats are doing - trying to suppress Fox news and talk radio and healthcare opposition (asking people to snitch on healthcare opponents by reporting them to whitehouse.gov) nationalizing banks and the auto industry,  etc etc.

Did you get all that or do you only have the attention “spand” (I think you meant span) of a goldfish?

Got anything else? Give it up while it’s clear you’re not going to get ahead. Go crawl back in your hole and work on that high school degree instead of displaying your ignorance blogging.

Slam!!

Source: dictionary.com


» on 11.24.09 @ 05:54 AM

“Everybody is going to learn to speak English if they live in this country. The issue is not whether or not future generations of immigrants are going to learn English. The question is how can we come up with both a legal, sensible immigration policy.”  -Barack Obama- (From debate with other Democratic candidates june 4, 2007.)

EVERYBODY is going to learn English?  I’d say that comment is pretty foolish.  I mean if your going to attack Republicans for saying foolish things, you should apply the same standards to Democrats.

You can click on the “watch video now” link near the bottom of the page of the following link if you want to hear him say the above quote.

http://glassbooth.org/explore/index/barack-obama/11/immigration/10/


» on 11.24.09 @ 06:15 AM

Thanks Noozhawk for some “balance” to Michelle Malkin.


» on 11.24.09 @ 08:06 AM

Local, move to China.  We don’t need you and your type here.


» on 11.24.09 @ 09:09 AM

I agree with Ron Dexter about this article supplying “balance” to the stable of Noozhawk columnists which include the malicious and mal-informed Miss Malkin. As I approach Malkin’s columns, I would recommend to readers like two cents and RKV: reading is optional, which, based upon two cents’ selective “research” on socialism, he already knows. What he fails to grasp by relying solely on conservative internet sources is that having social programs, as the US does and is looking to broaden, does not a socialistic government make (for evidence, see: the EU and the predominance of Social Democracies which also embrace market-based economies - although better regulated, generally, than the recent US Republican regime would like). While people like two cents and RKV want to see the world as black-and-white, it is, sadly and fortunately, gray.


» on 11.24.09 @ 09:11 AM

David, thanks for sharing your viewpoint. After 8 years of childish impulsiveness and thoughtless choices, I am so grateful to have a President who actually uses his brain to consider potential ramifications…even if I may not agree with all of his decisions.

It is likely these same people who trumpet unrealistic expectations of just how much Obama should have accomplished after only 10 months in office. Most of this country’s problems were 8 years or longer in the making and cannot be resolved overnight, or with the same knee-jerk reactionism that got us here in the first place.

Patience and deliberation…I like that in a leader.


» on 11.24.09 @ 10:05 AM

My Two Cents can use a dictionary. Actually, my two cents maybe used Google. So George Bush was too liberal for you? Wow, you and Glenn Beck,Sean Hannity and Sarah Palin must be buddies?

Sorry but Bush was a corporate fascist!! He and Cheney utilized extensive control via corporations to dictate policy at the expense of the people. He did forcibly suppress any opposition. He dictated in black and white. He rewarded loyalty and suppressed any descenting opinions to the point of fabricating information. Look at Iraq and the Scooter Libby debacle, our so-called energy policy created by Cheney behind closed doors and the use of no bid contracts to satisfy his military industrial complex and Haliburton buddies.

My two cents and RKV should move to Texas where corporatus neo-cons like yourselves will feel right at home. The extreme economic deprivation in this country is being addressed by Obama via policy changes. It is about time that the middle class be given a break. Without a strong middle class in this country, We the People, cannot survive.


» on 11.24.09 @ 11:28 AM

Hello David,

I get what you are saying.  If this war just popped up, I would agree.  Bad decisions get people killed.

Unfortunately, Obama and all the people he has appointed to his administration have been lambasting the previous administration for not making good decisions about Afghanistan.  He ridiculed and talked about how he would handle things if elected.

He has since been elected and has had since January to figure out what he wanted to do in Afghanistan.  The Generals request for additional troops has been floating around since long before it came out in the News.

So, what the complainers of Obama are saying is “He has had plenty of time to learn about the situation and make a decision”. 

The more time he wastes, the lower morale goes because the troops have no direction other than “Stand around and wait”.  This is not leadership.

The Afghan people are also growing nervous as they have helped the troops.  If our President is getting cold feet, how do you think the Afghan people feel.

Obama needs to pull his head out of the sand and make a decision.  He has had 12 months of briefings (they started briefing him right after the elections) and years of complaining that he knew better and wanted to return the fight to Afghanistan.

He talks the talk.  Does he walk the walk?

You might try remembering the realities instead of trying to find ways to protect him. 

By the way, tell your boy Obama to leave the terrorists in Guantanamo Bay.  We are the first generation to be stupid enough to think that trying War Crimes (Terrorism is a War Crime) in a civilian court with Miranda Rights etc. is a good idea.

I think our parents need to beat some sense into us.  Oh, that’s right.  The Yellow Bellied Liberals that are too afraid of their children to discipline them took away a parents right to spank their kids when they are being idiots.

So, yes, I agree with you, the Obama Administration is turning things into an Idiocracy.


» on 11.24.09 @ 12:58 PM

Has the columnist conveniently forgotten the deadlines set by Mr. President himself with regard to the passing of health care reform?  His original deadline didn’t even allow our legislators the opportunity to read what they were supposed to vote on.  Huh?  And we all know that the sky was going to fall if his deadline wasn’t met.  However, I still see the sky up above my head and our legislators are now actually reading and working on health care reform.  So, given that he’s had a whole year to come to some kind of decision on Afghanistan but was allowing legislators mere days/weeks to come to a decision on health care, I wonder who’s the idiot.


» on 11.24.09 @ 05:24 PM

Jim in SB is right. It doesn’t take all day to figure out America screwed up by keeping troops in the middle-east this long. The old Soviet Union collapsed making the same mistake. The fact that Obama still can’t figure that out and doesn’t act or make a decision, makes him look like an idiot and your article’s theme of waiting makes you seem pretty dull-minded.


» on 11.24.09 @ 06:24 PM

If 2cents and his co-belligerents would get their news from more diverse sources they would realize that the administration has spent this time crafting an exit strategy for this new committment of troops . Too bad the previous administration lacked the brains and ethics to do the same.


» on 11.24.09 @ 11:08 PM

o0O Hmmm… he disagrees with me, well he must listen to Glenn Beck,Sean Hannity and Sarah Palin because nobody thinks for themselves in this country except for those three. Nobody has their own mind. Anyone who disagrees with me must all be mentally connected psychicly with Sarah Palin, Glenn Beck and Sean Hannity and Cheney.

What great powers of association you have local, but no defense of your original ignorant comment:

“I am sure that my two cents has no idea what communism and socialism are. The first piece of evidence of their ignorance is to put the two terms together when they are completely different forms of government.”

And then right on to the tired old Bush/Cheney/Halliburton stuff we all heard for eight years that you STILL can’t get over. So predictable. You fell into the trap just like Elmer Fudd falling into his own trap setup by the intellectually superior Bugs Bunny. You’re a parrot repeating stuff you heard without an original thought in your head.

You should have followed my advice - Give it up while it’s clear you’re not going to get ahead. You’re ignorance is still showing.

I used the dictionary for YOUR benefit not mine. You obviously needed one, you can’t spell let alone know what the words mean. I knew your first reaction would be to try to discredit what I was saying. So I took it word for word from the credible source.

Here’s some more advice:
Don’t go to Harvard if you are one of the high school dropouts you spoke of in the first comment of yours. But thanks for continuously showing us what a lib is all about.

~Just my two cents

P.S Haliburton Cheny Palin Bush Glenn Beck Sean Hannity Scooter Libby Fox News!!! Is that the extent of your vocabulary? Get over it. Learn some new words.


» on 11.25.09 @ 12:13 AM

One thing I agree with you on local is:

“It is about time that the middle class be given a break. Without a strong middle class in this country, We the People, cannot survive.”

Tat is far from what is happening though.
Do you do that by creating more and more energy taxes for the businesses that would hire them and promote them? Do you do that by creating more and more wasteful government programs and more and more spending and debt that they will have to pay for somehow?


» on 11.25.09 @ 12:21 AM

In case you didn’t get it the first time, fascism is not the government utilizing “extensive control via corporations” it is the opposite: government controlling corporations (like is happening now). So Bush may have been a lot of things, but not a fascist. It sound good though doesn’t it?

I know you’re envious of my ability to use a dictionary, but you might try to learn to use one yourself before dragging out Bush Cheny Palin Beck anytime you get frustrated with your lack of intellect.

You threw the first shot bud.


» on 11.25.09 @ 12:38 PM

My two cents, you are having a battle of wits with an unarmed adversary. Please stop. It’s embarrassing that such conversation is allowed to expose the utter mental deficiency of the political left. In addition to the wobbling, indecisive Commander in Chief (oh, that’s right, in lift wing speak an indecision is being “thoughtful”), we now have the anthropogenic global warming hoax exposed. The tragedy in this incident is that real scientist will now be compromised by a few liars and cheats. Unfortunately the idiot left in this country and around the industrialized world has hitched their political credibility on the liars instead of the few scientists who still practice good old fashioned skepticism rather than “political science”. But for the author of this unmitigated bunch of baloney you really need to check that intellectual narcissism out their buddy or your little slavish lap dogs (ya you Local), will just follow you right over that cliff.


More Local News »

Michael Rattray: Preservation Vs. Retreat at Goleta Beach Park

A permanent solution is critical to maintaining the value of the community treasure

Joe Conason: Right Wing Gone Wild

Elizabeth Cheney, Glenn Beck et al take accusations of treason to the extreme

Tony Strickland: State Health-Care Bill an Ill Fit for Californians

Voters should have the power to protect themselves from state and federal health-care mandates

Eva Inbar: Foes of Curb Extensions Can’t See the Safety for the Cars

Milpas Street bulb-outs are not our biggest challenge; in fact, they can protect our most precious assets

Jerry Bunin: County Shortsighted in Funding Long-Range Planning

Poor decisions by the Board of Supervisors contributes to our continuing budget woes

Weather: Fog 54.0º


© Malamute Ventures LLC 2007-2010 | ISSN No. 1947-6086

Web Design & Development by PixelFive