
The U.S. Supreme Court, in West Virginia v. Environmental Protection Agency, punctuated the reality that its 6-3 conservative majority has become a political body more interested in restoring 19th-century values than upholding precedents and dealing with reality — including the existential threat of climate change.
Given the power of the Supreme Court, it’s important that we understand its recent rulings are connected. The justices are attempting to take us back to a past time we cannot afford to return to.
For example, 67% of women disapprove of overturning Roe v. Wade. 59% of voters want stricter gun laws. Two-thirds of Americans think the government should do more to prevent climate change.
Yet, without relying on past precedents (stare decisis) the Supreme Court overturned a half-century constitutional right ensuring women have the right to control their own bodies, taking them back to the 1800s when they didn’t even have the right to vote (Dobbs v. Jackson); allowed more guns on our streets (New York State Rifle & Pistol Association Inc. v. Bruen) returning us to a time when people were routinely armed in public; and stopped the EPA from regulating coal-fired power plants as if the world was not in the midst of a greenhouse gas climate crisis (West Virginia v. EPA).
While it’s important that we acknowledge the dangers of all three decisions, it’s critical we understand that the EPA/climate change ruling has an impact on the entire world.
While the West Virginia ruling is a right-wing judicial attack restricting the powers of administrative agencies like the EPA, it, at the expense of the United States fighting global warming, is protecting the coal industry. (One of the petitioners in the case was the State of West Virginia that, after Wyoming, produces the most U.S. coal.)
Coal is a fossil fuel. It is the single largest source of global temperature rise, and is the dirtiest and most destructive of the greenhouse gases. Climate scientists are clear that continued coal emissions alone, worldwide, will ensure that our climate’s temperature goes over the 1.5C “tipping point” by midcentury, increasing the most devastating impacts of climate change.
Nevertheless, the Supreme Court, without focusing on climate change and the role coal plays in it, framed the issue as “whether restructuring the nation’s overall mix of electricity generation to transition from 38% to 27% coal by 2030 can be the best system of emissions reduction within the meaning of (the Clean Air Act) Section 111.” The court concluded it was NOT and prohibited EPA from doing so.
Most emissions from coal are in the electricity sector. There are 241 coal-fired plants across the United States generating 22% of U.S. power. This is twice as much electricity generated from coal than wind and solar.
As in Roe, the Supreme Court ignored its own precedent in reaching its conclusion. In 2007, the court in Massachusetts v. EPA ruled that: “Greenhouse gases fit well within the Clean Air Act’s definition of air pollutant.”
President Joe Biden’s administration’s approach to combating the climate emergency was to work toward a 50% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions from 2005 levels by 2030. To do that, the electricity sector would have to replace its coal- and natural gas-fired power plants with wind, solar and other clean sources of energy.
This approach was contained in Biden’s “Build Back Better” bill that could not get through a 50-50 Senate. The EPA regulating emissions from coal-powered electrical plants, therefore, became essential to achieving that goal.
But the six Republican-appointed, conservative justices on the Supreme Court intervened, ensuring that the goal will not be met and that the United States will not have the credibility to lead the global fight against global warming.
So, what do these Supreme Court rulings mean for Santa Barbarans? Coal-fired power plants operating in Arizona and Nevada will continue to send coal pollutants into our air (and greenhouse gases into the atmosphere). More guns will be on our streets. Women from other states will be coming here for abortions.
Perhaps most important, it means that when we vote in November, we must consider which candidates will support federal legislation combating these regressive rulings.
— Environmental lawyer Robert Sulnick represented the community of Casmalia in litigation against the Casmalia Resources Hazardous Waste Landfill, co-founded the American Oceans Campaign with Ted Danson, and is a partner in the Santa Barbara environmental consulting firm Environmental Problem Solving Enterprises. Click here for previous columns. The opinions expressed are his own.
