Santa Barbara again finds itself in the midst of a historic environmental issue. In 1969, the Santa Barbara oil spill spawned a national environmental movement. In 2022, deciding whether to close California’s last remaining nuclear power plant, near Avila Beach in San Luis Obispo County, has created a climate change debate we cannot avoid.

Diablo Canyon’s Unit 1 reactor was scheduled to shut down in November 2024, followed by Unit 2 shutting down in August 2025.

However, with the backing of Gov. Gavin Newsom and President Joe Biden’s administration, Diablo Canyon’s operator, PG&E, received an extension until Sept. 6 to apply for funding from the Civil Nuclear Credit Program to keep the plant operating.

Rep. Salud Carbajal, D-Santa Barbara, correctly criticized Newsom’s and Biden’s approaches because they didn’t involve the local people and organizations that planned the plant’s decommissioning.

A disaster at Diablo Canyon would catastrophically affect both San Luis Obispo and Santa Barbara counties. Local municipalities and citizens should join the conversation and oppose the plant remaining open.

Granted, we are in the midst of a global climate change crisis; nuclear power plants, while not entirely greenhouse gas-free, do not themselves emit GHGs; and Diablo Canyon accounts for almost 9% of California’s in-state electricity generation.

However, this is neither the time nor the place to be operating a nuclear power plant.

There is no such thing as a zero emissions-free nuclear power plant. These facilities require continuous mining of the uranium needed to feed the plants. The mining emits greenhouse gases.

Diablo Canyon is threatened by earthquakes. The plant sits near several earthquake faults, both on land and in the ocean, with one only 2,000 feet from the facility.

After the Fukushima Daaichi Nuclear Plant accident in the devastating 2011 Japan earthquake and tsunami, the earthquake risk should be taken very seriously.

The Japan disaster cut power to the Fukushima plant and wiped out its emergency generators. Three reactor cores subsequently exploded, releasing the highest amount of radioactivity into the environment since the 1986 Chernobyl nuclear disaster in Ukraine, the worst in history.

When similar earthquake concerns surfaced at other nuclear power plants in the United States, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission stopped those plants from operating until the agency determined they met earthquake safety regulations. That has not happened at Diablo Canyon.

“Spent fuel” is nuclear waste. We don’t know how to dispose of it, so we store it on site. Until 2009, Diablo Canyon stored its waste in two massive cooling pools. The facility now moves its spent fuel from the pools about every seven years, placing it in large concrete and steel containers within a stone’s throw from the ocean.

During the last government survey in 2013, there were 2,848 spent fuel assemblies stored at Diablo Canyon. That number has obviously increased since then.

To date, 1.5% of all nuclear power plants, worldwide, have melted down to some degree.

During the Fukushima disaster, approximately 80% of the fallout happened over the Pacific Ocean. According to studies, radioactive contamination from Fukishima has drifted to within 99 miles of the California coast.

The Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution in Massachusetts reports that radioactive compounds in the ocean are transmitted up the food chain to fish, marine mammals and humans.

Should we suffer a similar accident, our precious signature coastline, which defines our community, would not only suffer food chain issues, it would be ruined, not to mention the lives that would be lost from the nuclear fallout.

California is the nation’s leader in providing green energy through renewables (59%). In this regard, Santa Barbara County is on track to meet its goal of carbon neutrality by 2045, reducing greenhouse gas emissions to 50% of 2018 levels.

This is the path we should continue down, and not veer off in favor of an uncontrollable “super human” power source. Diablo Canyon should be shut down on schedule.

— Environmental lawyer Robert Sulnick represented the community of Casmalia in litigation against the Casmalia Resources Hazardous Waste Landfill, co-founded the American Oceans Campaign with Ted Danson, and is a partner in the Santa Barbara environmental consulting firm Environmental Problem Solving Enterprises. Click here for previous columns. The opinions expressed are his own.

Environmental lawyer Robert Sulnick represented the community of Casmalia in litigation against the Casmalia Resources Hazardous Waste Landfill, co-founded the American Oceans Campaign with Ted Danson, and is a partner in the Santa Barbara environmental consulting firm Environmental Problem Solving Enterprises. The opinions expressed are his own.