Local fisheries management is under threat of shifting from science-based management to political whim-based management. I’m calling foul play.

Our fisheries are immeasurably important to us for reasons of economics, culture, recreation and subsistence.

Fisheries have long been managed by four fisheries management councils around the country including our own Pacific Fisheries Management Council (PFMC), under the Magnuson Stevens Act, which defines fisheries management between federal and state agencies.

Over my lifetime, I’ve seen our fisheries managed amazingly well and adaptively to accommodate changes (climate and others) that affect our ocean wildlife. The PFMC has all the right people in place — fisheries scientists, expert advisory panels for various fisheries, stakeholders, and strong working relationships with wildlife management agencies in each of our western states.

Here comes trouble: At a recent council meeting of the PFMC, Bill Douros the regional director of the NOAA – Sanctuaries office of National Marine Sanctuaries (ONMS) attended and addressed the council, and I characterize the conversation here.

Douros is involved with designating the proposed Chumash Heritage Sanctuary off our central California coast; however, I believe his comments and questions could apply to any sanctuary across the nation.

Douros wanted to know if whenever sanctuaries came to the PFMC and asked for a fisheries management decision, would the PFMC grant their request.

The PFMC chair assured him that the PFMC is the right place to bring fisheries issues because the PFMC has fisheries scientists, expert advisory panels for the various fisheries, stakeholder relations, and working relations with the wildlife management agencies in the states under its jurisdiction.

The council advised Douros that any request that passes muster and makes good sense in terms of science will be given strong consideration for approval and implementation.

However, when a fisheries management request doesn’t reach the high bar for scientific and expert consideration, it will not be implemented.

Douros seemed to get his back up and suggested the PFMC should grant requests from ONMS regardless.

The chair of the PFMC asked Douros if he was saying that if a request from ONMS did not make scientific sense and was turned down, that ONMS would do it anyway.

I understand that Douros replied that ONMS could do that.

Here is where I am calling foul play. ONMS does not have fisheries management scientists in charge of our precious nation’s fisheries. They do not have expert panels for the various fisheries. They are not professional fisheries managers.

Where the PFMC under the Magnuson Stevens Act provides science-based management with the overall goal of sustainability, the ONMS under the Sanctuaries Act provides political-based management with the overall goal of protection which can mean fishing closures without scientific need.

I faithfully served for 16 years on the Channel Islands National Marine Sanctuary Advisory Council, and I know from personal experience that many people and organizations involved with ONMS have a goal of protecting vast zones by locking out people who want to fish. They have a history of supporting measures that restrict access to our healthy and well-managed fish stocks, and their reasons stem from political pressure from extreme protectionist organizations.

My point is that fisheries management by politics instead of by science is wrong. We need our federal representatives in the House and Senate to tell the ONMS to back away from fisheries management, and instead leave it to the professionals at the regional fisheries management councils.

Capt. David Bacon is a boating safety consultant and expert witness, with a background in high-tech industries and charter boat ownership and operation. He teaches classes for Santa Barbara City College and, with a lifelong interest in wildlife, writes outdoors columns for Noozhawk and other publications. The opinions expressed are his own.