In May 2020, the City of Santa Barbara closed State Street to vehicle traffic downtown to help restaurants survive the economic devastation of the COVID-19 pandemic.

It was a reasonable response to an extraordinary emergency, and many business owners supported it.

Yet long after the pandemic emergency had passed, State Street remained closed.

As the months turned into years, many of us accepted the closure with the understanding that the city was exploring ideas for State Street’s future.

There were studies, community meetings, surveys, consultants and countless discussions about what downtown could become.

Six years and considerable public expense later, we still have essentially the same temporary street configuration established in 2020, with no completed transformation in sight.

But while the city was planning for the future, many of us were watching conditions downtown get worse, not better.

For generations, State Street has been the economic heart of Santa Barbara. Its shops, galleries, restaurants and independent businesses depended on accessibility and visibility.

Customers driving through downtown discovered storefronts and returned to shop. That exposure was especially important beyond the busiest restaurant blocks.

As the closure continued, merchants reported declining customer traffic and lost sales. Some businesses closed. Others struggled to survive.

Online shopping, rising costs and changing consumer habits contributed to downtown’s challenges, but removing vehicle access also eliminated a longstanding source of visibility without providing an effective alternative for many businesses.

The concerns extended beyond lost visibility. Merchants and residents described problems with fast-moving electric bicycles, homelessness, crime and an atmosphere they felt was becoming less welcoming.

As a downtown business owner myself, I increasingly heard from people who said they no longer visited State Street because of accessibility, safety concerns or simply because downtown no longer offered the experience they once enjoyed.

These problems have multiple causes, but they deserve attention. Instead, the city continued planning while many businesses struggled with the conditions they faced every day.

Meanwhile, organizations such as Strong Towns Santa Barbara advocated for a permanent pedestrian-oriented downtown, and the City Council continued extending the closure while pursuing its long-term vision.

I founded the State Street Business Alliance to bring merchants’ concerns to city leadership.

We gathered more than 1,000 signatures and approximately 600 written comments from residents and businesses. I presented our findings at council meetings and met individually with council members.

We were not asking to turn back the clock. We were asking for compromise.

Our proposal was to restore slow, controlled vehicle access to portions of State Street while preserving outdoor dining and pedestrian gathering spaces. We believed there was room for both.

But despite our efforts, nothing meaningful changed.

At times, it has felt as though the City Council was treating State Street like its own remodeling project, rather than recognizing its decisions were affecting the livelihoods of downtown businesses and the community that depends on them.

When I asked Councilwoman — now mayor-elect — Kristen Sneddon why State Street remained closed, her repeated response was that an “overwhelming number of people wanted it that way.”

Yet our efforts revealed a substantial number of residents and business owners who felt otherwise, raising serious questions about whether the city was listening to the full range of public opinion.

Surveys have shown support for a pedestrian promenade, and those opinions deserve consideration. But what about the people who signed our petition, submitted written comments, and described the financial consequences of the closure?

Mayor Randy Rowse has acknowledged that business and property owners felt dismissed and unheard. That reflects my experience.

The city subsequently approved its State Street Master Plan.

According to Noozhawk’s Nov. 10 reporting, the project carries an estimated $96 million price tag and could take six years to construct, with no complete funding plan as of yet.

How will businesses survive years of construction? How will customers and deliveries reach them? What assistance will be available to struggling merchants?

A vision for tomorrow must account for the businesses paying rent today.

After the council approved the master plan and extended the Title 31 framework, the Committee to Reopen State Street, supported by Jim Knell of SIMA Corp., launched a referendum challenging that decision.

About 8,700 signatures were gathered in just three weeks, well above the 5,483 required

Some critics have characterized the referendum as an effort by wealthy property owners protecting their investments, but small businesses were raising these concerns long before the referendum campaign began.

On Nov. 10, the City Council voted 5-1-1 to approve an urgency ordinance maintaining the closure while the referendum proceeds.

Sneddon and Council members Oscar Gutierrez, Meagan Harmon, Mike Jordan and Wendy Santamaria voted for the closure, with Rowse in dissent and Councilman Eric Friedman abstaining.

Attorneys representing the referendum committee argue that the city cannot enact substantially similar regulations while a referendum challenging the previous ordinance is pending.

They maintain that doing so interferes with California’s constitutional referendum protections and question whether the scheduled expiration of Title 31 constitutes a legitimate emergency.

The city disagrees, arguing that maintaining the closure avoids the expense of reopening State Street only to potentially close it again.

The dispute may now have to be resolved in court, potentially at additional taxpayer expense.

At that same Nov. 10 meeting, several council members acknowledged the missed opportunities.

“I didn’t want to compromise one inch from the vision I had,” Harmon said.

Friedman explained his abstention:

“My abstention is a protest in the fact that we didn’t do what we needed to do when we had the chance.”

Jordan also acknowledged that the city had reached the point of defending its position rather than talking with people who felt unheard.

These statements speak directly to how we arrived here.

It did not have to come to this.

Six years ago, State Street was closed to help businesses survive. Today, some of those same businesses are asking for help surviving the consequences of that closure.

The people who want State Street reopened are not enemies of progress. They are merchants, residents, customers and taxpayers who care deeply about Santa Barbara.

We have spent six years discussing what State Street might become. Perhaps it is time to give equal consideration to the businesses and people who make it what it is today.

Santa Barbara deserves a thriving downtown, a government willing to listen, and a City Council prepared to find the compromise that could have prevented this controversy in the first place.

Colleen Macey is the founder of Santa Barbara Interiors, at 10 E. Figueroa St. downtown and a member of the State Street Business Alliance. The opinions expressed are her own.