A class-action lawsuit filed by a Carpinteria Valley advocacy group dedicated to curbing cannabis odors is headed to trial next month.
The case was originally set to be heard in November, according to Santa Barbara Coalition for Responsible Cannabis spokesperson Lionel Neff, but it was delayed by Judge Thomas Anderle’s retirement.
The trial on Dec. 18 will now be heard in Judge Donna Geck’s courtroom.
The coalition, a nearby rose farm and a neighbor filed the lawsuit in September 2023 against Casitas Pass Road cannabis farms, alleging the operations were emitting an “ever-present noxious odor” that interfered with the use of nearby properties.
Both the farms’ vapor-phase systems — which emitted a “laundromat”-like odor to help mask the cannabis — and cannabis itself have harmed nearby neighbors, the lawsuit alleged.
Anderle certified the lawsuit as a class action last year.
He ruled that residents who live within a mile of Valley Crest (9 acres at 5980 Casitas Pass Road) and Ceres Farms (9.5 acres at 6030 Casitas Pass Road) and purchased their properties before Jan. 19, 2016, could join the case.
Neff told Noozhawk earlier this month that the class now includes 200 homeowners.
The lawsuit is now set to solely move forward against Valley Crest because Ceres Farms has settled with the coalition for an undisclosed amount, according to Neff.
Valley Crest Farms LLC leases the property, which is owned by the VanWingerden family, Neff said.
State records list Philip Fagundes as Valley Crest Farms LLC’s CEO.
Lawyers for Valley Crest did not respond to a Noozhawk request for comment.
All operational Carpinteria cannabis farms have discontinued those vapor-phase systems that the plaintiffs had initially sued over in 2023, at the direction of the county Board of Supervisors.
The operations have now all installed multi-technology carbon scrubbers or an equivalent technology. Cannabis businesses in the Carpinteria Valley are largely using mixed-light greenhouses for cultivation operations.
A county spokesperson told Noozhawk in October that 16 cannabis operators have had approved odor-abatement plans, while the remaining eight were still under review by the county.
But there’s some debate about how well the equivalents work, Neff told Noozhawk earlier this month.
“Let me put it this way: (the odor is) not as bad as it was before, but it’s still unacceptable,” he said. “…Why should we accept better than it was?”
Some farms, including Ceres, have installed Evinity scrubbers. Those are roughly $22,000 each, with a recommended 10 per acre.
Valley Crest has installed Genesis scrubbers, with 12 per acre, per Superior Court records. They had purchased 45 units.
Neff said the Genesis scrubbers do not have carbon, and that testing showed they were 41% effective at the greenhouse vents compared to Evinity, which was 85% effective at the vents.
Genesis scrubbers are also cheaper, he said: between $10,000 and $12,000.
Cannabis Odor Complaints
The county tests odor at the property line using nasal rangers, a portable olfactometer that measures odor strength.
The maximum threshold allowed under county rules is 4 d/t for less than three minutes.
A Sept. 2 test found that the odor of cannabis could be detected for exactly three minutes, according to the county’s cannabis odor dashboard.
A county employee testified in September that the test showed that the operation’s odor control system “has not eliminated odors” to the level required by the county, per Superior Court records.
No other tests between April 2025 to date found Valley Crest violations of that 4 d/t standard.
The dashboard shows that 34 odor complaints have been filed about Valley Crest from October 2025 to Nov. 13, 2026.
Nine were filed between Oct. 13 and Nov. 13.

