The vacant lot at the corner of Castillo and Montecito streets in Santa Barbara one day is expected to be home to a small hotel.
What it will look like, however, is still a big work in progress.
The Historic Landmarks Commission on Wednesday delivered some stern feedback to developer Ed St. George and his architectural team. The project was before them for a concept review.
The proposal is for a nine-room hotel on a vacant lot, nine parking spaces in a 3,559-square-foot parking garage, and 472 square feet of storage and mechanical room space. The project includes a site wall around the development, a trash room, bicycle storage, roof-mounted solar panels, an outdoor seating area and landscaping, and a slight relocation of the existing access on West Montecito Street.
The project is proposed as an annex to the approved hotel at 302 and 308 W. Montecito St.
The lot is across the street from the 7-Eleven and near Santa Cruz Market.
The commissioners expressed concern about the design of the building. Since the meeting was only concept review, there was no formal vote, only verbal feedback.
Commissioner Ed Lenvik said he did not like the design, particularly on the side facing Montecito Street.
“We really expect street frontages to be pedestrian friendly,” he said. “I find the elevation of this building to be the most unfriendly elevation I can imagine. I don’t see this as a pedestrian-friendly frontage at all.”
He also pushed back against a round, decorative element toward the front corner of the building.
“It is a superfluous piece of architecure that is not needed on this building,” Lenvik said. “I can’t imagine why we would ever need to have that element there as a functioning piece of architecture. To me, it is a really poor excuse to try to create something with some dignity to it.”
Commissioner Steve Hausz was more optimistic about the overall building, but he said that the Montecito Street elevation is not friendly.
“It does not feel like something that would be pleasant to view as a pedestrian walking down the sidewalk,” Hausz said. “That garage still needs a lot of study.”
St. George has an approved 32-room hotel at the other end of the street, at 302 and 308 W. Montecito St. He agreed to also build six affordable housing units somewhere else in the city as part of the hotel project.
The debate between housing and hotels has been a focal point of political controversy for the community. The Historic Landmarks Commission’s comments were only on the design and not the actual project. The current site is a weedy lot. The project is also next to the Sahyan Library, at 316 Castillo St., which is on the city’s Historic Resources Inventory.
Commissioner Keith Butler asked, “Where’s the front of this building?”
“This doesn’t have an entry to it,” Butler said. “I recognize it’s an annex to further down the street, but if I were walking back to here, to my hotel room, from Santa Cruz Market next door, whatever, where’s the front of this place? How do I get in?”
The project, designed by ON Design Architects LLC, will return to the HLC after it is revised.
St. George told Noozhawk after the meeting that he appreciated the HLC’s feedback. With nearby liquor stores, a heavy presence of homeless people and loitering in the area, St. George said the area could use a change.
“My hope is that with the addition of our small boutique hotel the area may begin to change for the better,” St. George said. “
— Noozhawk staff writer Joshua Molina can be reached at jmolina@noozhawk.com. Follow Noozhawk on Twitter: @noozhawk, @NoozhawkNews and @NoozhawkBiz. Connect with Noozhawk on Facebook.
