With all the talk about Homer’s “Odyssey” — not just the recent movie — let’s interpret this story of a western protagonist’s “trail” across the sea in search of … booty, fame and vengeance.
The story begins in Homer’s earlier epic poem “The Iliad,” which opens with the famous lines: Sing Goddess of the Wrath of Achilles who fought before the walls of Troy with Odysseus and the Greeks. I believe the story focuses on male human anger and the many stupidities and abominations resulting from the Greeks’ daring raid on Troy.
Today, we observe human arrogance (hubris) as President Donald Trump’s administration seeks to gut key protections in the landmark National Historic Preservation Act. The legislation has protected cultural resources, historic sites and vital indigenous areas from development since 1966 (see 4.1.1. for details).
In the essential parts of Section 106 of this act, the “new” board of the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation would weaken protections of public lands, weaken tribal consultation requirements, and reduce public input about development impacting iconic public places (e.g. the Grand Canyon).
Any reasonable reader of the ACHP’s new amendments to Section 106 can see that these changes would drastically diminish the effectiveness of Section 106’s protection of historic and cultural places in the United States.
Both the reliable National Trust for Historic Preservation and the National Parks Conservation Association have roundly condemned these proposed changes. In particular, public participation in the 106 review process would be eliminated: Ordinary citizens would not be able to voice their concerns about wholesale commercial development next to or at cultural resources.
I’ve been a member of the voluntary Forest Service group Partners in Preservation (of cultural resources) since 2016, and our main mission is to preserve cultural resources in Los Padres National Forest.
The “human arrogance” aspect of the new changes resembles the anger of Achilles and the brutal cunning of Odysseus because they are heedless of the consequences of their actions. Unlike the sappy ending of Christopher Nolan’s exciting film, in Homer’s poem, Odysseus instructs his son Telemachus to murder the 12 disloyal serving women after he himself has killed all the suitors in his hall at Ithaca (Book XXII).
Today’s developers who control the departments of Agriculture and Interior want to run roughshod over sensitive and delicate natural treasures as well as historic AND indigenous sites needing protection from runaway commercialization. For example, the sacred mountain Soxtonocmu (Figueroa Mountain) is within our Los Padres National Forest. Diluting Section 106 would limit local and Chumash resistance to commercial development there.
How about building a large and fancy “glamping” resort on the beautiful and sacrosanct peak there? The Agriculture Department could approve what it wants with little or no public or indigenous review.
After getting rid of more than 20 members of the Advisory Council, the new handpicked Trump appointees voted 16-5 for amendments to Section 106 that would expand the federal government’s power to build or renovate historic sites by drastically reducing oversight mechanisms written into the original 60-year-old act.
I understand that some of the impetus from this administration’s commercialization thrust has to do with the president’s plans for a gargantuan and gaudy triumphal arch meant to be constructed in Washington, D.C., near Arlington National Cemetery (see my July article).
It is no coincidence that, just as a Section 106 review process has been invoked for the proposed arch, a Trump-dominated Advisory Council simultaneously decides to gut key provisions of 106. In a July 21 letter, the venerable National Trust for Historic Preservation testified that the Advisory Council’s review of 106 has been too hurried. Obviously, the president wants the arch to go up NOW, just like the reflecting pool repaint had to be accomplished immediately, and we all know how THAT has worked out — over budget, poorly done, needs a redo.
One can feel the obfuscation and pseudo-urgency of the Advisory Council’s recommended changes to weaken the landmark National Historic Preservation Act, an important law passed by our Congress in more environmentally conscious times. The 1966 act remains crucial and establishes a precise procedural framework to protect our nation’s sensitive cultural and historic places.
Just as the Interior and Agriculture departments have pushed for roads (and consequent development) into certain roadless national forest areas, the Advisory Council’s amendments to Section 106 will lead to increased commodification of our precious natural lands.
Sowing confusion amid complexities is part of this administration’s goal. There will certainly be a rash of lawsuits over the proposed changes to Section 106 — the current federal government relishes them since they will create more complexity, take more time and further confuse the public. The public’s uncertainties allow for continued disorder, and disorder is one of autocracy’s best friends.
One should think the federal government would want to cherish vital cultural and historic resources in our country rather than make this daring raid on historic sites! There are many civilian service groups such as Santa Barbara’s PIP team who attempt to do this in the face of today’s intensely pro-development federal government. The proposed changes dilute cultural protections and the authors display a Homeric level of arrogance in their heedlessness of the consequences of their actions.
Chippewa leader Michaela Pavlat comments about these proposed changes to Section 106 of our National Historic Preservation Act: “The National Parks Conservation Association wholeheartedly objects to this calculated, yet unwarranted attack on tribal consultation, historic preservation, and the regulations that have protected the places that tell our country’s diverse stories.”
4.1.1.
Letter from the National Trust for Historic Preservation’s Elizabeth Merritt dated July 21 to Travis Voyles, the acting chair of the ACHP (the ACHP has had the chairmanship left vacant, as is typical for the Trump administration). Michaela Pavlat (Ste. Sault Marie Tribe of Chippewa Indians) is manager of the National Parks Conservation Indigenous Partnerships Program.

