The Santa Maria City Council narrowly rejected a mixed-use project proposing housing, business space and indoor pickleball courts on an empty lot once eyed for a church.
However, the rejection, following concerns from neighbors and council members about traffic, parking and more, could leave the site vulnerable to higher-density development under relaxed state housing laws.
A divided council voted 3-2 on Tuesday to deny the project, with support from Mayor Alice Patino, Councilwoman Gloria Flores and Councilman Richard Batalla. It’s rare for the Santa Maria City Council to deny a project with housing.
The Courtyard at Hidden Pines proposed six single-family homes, a two-story apartment building with eight units, a commercial component for small shops, indoor pickleball courts and a courtyard at 2415 Railroad Ave.
Batalla cited traffic and parking concerns, especially because of the proximity to Tommie Kunst Junior High School, for his opposition.
“People don’t even pay attention when school’s in session, so I can just imagine the more traffic this is going to bring to that area,” Batalla said, adding that more apartments would cause “a big mess as far as the parking.”
Councilwoman Maribel Aguilera-Hernandez, who voted against the denial while expressing support for the project with colleague Gloria Soto, noted that the council’s rejection could lead to an increase in the price of housing.

“Whenever we vote down housing projects, we are thereby voting to increase the cost of housing because we have less inventory,” she said. “So, some of us are getting priced out of housing. Even rentals are just so expensive for people.”
Before the council’s vote, Community Development Director Chenin Dow said that state lawmakers have effectively eliminated single-family zoning in California by easing rules to boost housing options.
Without the mixed-use proposal, a single-family project on the 2.8 acres could see up to 56 units or more under state law changes that allow accessory dwelling units and junior accessory dwelling units.
“In a single-family zoning scenario, because single-family zoning effectively no longer exists, the densities could be much, much higher,” Dow added, “and we are not able to require parking or weigh in on the design or the character of that construction.”
The Courtyard at Hidden Pines proposed a density of five units per acre, below the eight units per acre allowed in the specific plan.
Before the council’s vote, several neighbors spoke against the project.
“Our third concern is density and neighborhood character. The proposed combination of uses is too much for this established residential neighborhood,” resident Roberta Thompson said.
Instead, the project should consider six to eight single-family homes to create a development that complements surrounding homes and neighborhood character, she added.
After the vote, the applicant’s land-use consultant noted that they expect to return with a project including 30 units for 2.8 acres site at the corner of Hidden Pines Way and Railroad Avenue.
In 2023, the applicant proposed 33 single-story units for a workforce housing project, prompting opposition and leading to crafting the Courtyard at Hidden Pines mixed-use development.
“Density is a real factor in doing projects. If this project doesn’t move forward, there are options,” Laurie Tamura, a land-use consultant for applicant Dan Patin, said before the council’s vote Tuesday. “I think that’s a reality that the city needs to consider when looking at this project.”
After the council’s denial, Tamura referred to prior housing proposals with 30 units.
“That’s what we’re going to come back with then, and we hope that the neighborhood will support it,” Tamura added.

