Am I the only person who is perplexed and dismayed by the idea behind the development at 1018 Garden St. that was just given the go-ahead by the Santa Barbara Planning Commission, as reported in the March 18 Noozhawk story, “Santa Barbara Planning Commission Supports Unique Hotel-Condo Project on Garden Street”?
Given that Santa Barbara is desperate for housing, this building could easily have been turned into studio apartments.
Two commission members voiced significant objections to this project, including the obvious one that an individual owner could likely try live in it themselves.
It’s hard to understand the rationale behind this unnecessary project, and how it got this far in the approval process.
Susan Shields
Santa Barbara
• • •
Regarding the March 19 story, “Santa Barbara School District to Adopt New English Language Curriculum,” I have spent the last 40 years teaching English literacy skills in schools and universities overseas.
I was therefore rather surprised to read about the Santa Barbara Unified School District’s solution to what it sees as the failure of elementary schools to teach children to read — “It must be because Curriculum A doesn’t work so let’s try Curriculum B.”
I was surprised because the article did not acknowledge anywhere the proportion of students at each grade level who do not have English as a first language, i.e. the language they speak at home.
These children, most of whom are growing up to become fluent bilinguals, should be celebrated if only because extensive research has demonstrated that bilingualism enhances executive functioning in the developing brain.
A vast amount of high-quality research has been done into the acquisition of reading skills by EAL (English as an Additional Language) children. It seems clear from this that the design of reading curricula for such students is far more complex than simply choosing between a phonics versus a context-based approach to instruction.
Among other things, any curriculum revision benefits from valuing and exploit each child’s first language in an approach known as “translanguaging.”
Finally, one task force member is quoted as having said, “We have very low literacy in this county. It’s really shocking.” No, it isn’t shocking. It’s simply indicative of the beautifully rich socio-cultural diversity of this county.
Robin Corcos
Goleta
• • •
The March 22 article, “Hundreds of Isla Vista Renters Face Eviction by New Owner of Apartments,” highlights a terrible injustice, but why does Noozhawk need to further victimize the residents by describing them as “LatinX”?
Most of the residents of these apartments are Latino. The LatinX crowd will move in after the renovictions.
H. Lopez
UC Santa Barbara
• • •
Regarding the March 22 article, “Lamborghini Driver’s License Suspended, Fined for 152 mph Ticket,” am I the only one who thinks a guy who can drop a half-a-million dollars on a sports car won’t be deterred by a paltry $1,950 fine and a 30-day suspension? Big whoop.
I really don’t understand what happened in this case.
Bob Moore
Santa Barbara
• • •
I’m a big fan of Noozhawk publisher Bill Macfadyen’s “Best of Bill” columns and his comments about the Lamborghini driver are the reasons why. His line about the Little Tikes Cozy Coupe was golden.
Susan Davis
Montecito
• • •
On Feb. 13, 2018, Santa Barbara County Supervisors Joan Hartmann, Steve Lavagnino, Das Williams and Janet Wolf approved an ordinance creating the cannabis tax rates and methods of collection, subject to voter approval on the June 2018 election ballot.
On June 5, 2018, 75.83% of voters in the county approved the Measure T cannabis tax.
Why the history lesson? Recent comments by elected officials and misinformation by anti-cannabis allies in support of fundraising efforts show they do not recall the exact words of the cannabis tax ballot initiative, which clearly said, “… estimated to raise between $5 and $25 million annually for general government purposes …”
The county’s cannabis tax receipts have consistently fallen within the range articulated in the ballot language. The revenue being collected matches what voters approved.
Estimating tax revenues for budgeting purposes is difficult. I am confident that the county budget staff is doing the best it can with the chaotic state of the legal cannabis wholesale market.
While on staff, I was public about the substantial risk of cannabis tax revenue volatility as the State of California made the transition from 90 years of prohibition to legalization.
EVERY jurisdiction in California is experiencing a decline of cannabis tax revenue, particularly those jurisdictions that are cannabis producers like Santa Barbara County.
Even Monterey County, often mentioned by opponents because its cultivation tax is acreage based, has seen significant declines in tax revenue. Monterey County has cut tax rates to help cannabis businesses while considering cutting cannabis staffing to match cannabis revenues and then offer that the cannabis industry may take 10 years to reach equilibrium.
If sales tax were to decline, would elected officials or their allies be asking for reconsideration of car dealership regulations since they are a large source of sales tax revenue?
If transient occupancy taxes (hotel bed taxes) were to decline, would those same people be calling for changing regulations or land use policies for hotels?
Audits should be happening every day. Payment of current taxes and back taxes must be collected. Businesses failing or avoiding cannabis taxes should have their annual business licenses revoked or not renewed as is allowed under current ordinances.
I would argue that recommending policy changes and engaging in fundraising with misinformation ought to rejected by all participants of a representative democracy. It leads us to multiple bad outcomes.
Consider this question: How can the county use lessons learned from other tax collections to improve the efficacy of collecting cannabis tax revenues?
Dennis Bozanich
Concord
• • •
I own a 2013 Toyota Prius, which is commonly targeted for catalytic converter theft due to the ease and value of the catalytic converters on these cars.
At 4:45 a.m. March 22, I was awakened by the sound of power tools, making me wonder “who is doing construction work at four in the morning?” Then I heard a BOOM (my car being dropped off of the jack) and the sound of a truck speeding away.
I couldn’t fall back asleep until I checked on my car, so I went outside and started it up only to be greeted by what sounded like a motorcycle. I knew my catalytic converter had been stolen just minutes prior.
I called 9-1-1 and posted about it on Reddit and had two other Santa Barbara locals respond to me saying that their Priuses were also robbed that morning. We’re upset, and wish there were better ways to protect our cars.
Clara Bakus
Santa Barbara
• • •
50 years ago, I graduated from Santa Barbara Junior High School and readied myself for the high school experience my friends and I had been waiting for. I still remember like it was yesterday our first day in the main Santa Barbara High hallway; it even smelled grown up.
Of course, it didn’t take me but a few weeks to meet my counselor, Robert “Bob” Blakeney, who looked more like a football player than a school counselor.
“Do you know why I called you into my office?” he asked. I answered no. He said, “I think you do.” I said no, I really don’t. He said, “OK, then I can I see your driver’s license?”
Now I’m thinking, how did he know? I said I didn’t have a driver’s license yet, and he then asked how I could drive a motorcycle to school?
I had been riding my mom’s Honda 90 for years and, when at the junior high school, I’d park it on Ortega Street and walk into the school. But now at high school almost everyone could drive so I figured who could possibly notice another kid on a motorcycle? This guy sure did.
Mr. Blakeney walked around his desk and put his big arm around my shoulder and began walking me out of his office. He said, “Ed, I’m giving you a week’s detention and I don’t want to see that bike on campus again until you have a license in your pocket.”
From that point on I was on Mr Blakeney’s radar. He knew if I was late or missed a class, and he would come find me. I did so much detention in that first semester that he and I got to know each other really well.
It turned out that Mr. Blakeney had a great sense of humor and I wasn’t too far off on my original assessment: He was a football and basketball player in college.
At one point, Mr. Blakeney had insisted on meeting my mother to discuss my truancy. Afterward, he called me into his office and his demeanor was completely different. The next time I had detention, instead of sitting in his office, we went for walk around the entire campus. We talked about everything, and I still remember that day so clearly.
From that point on, Mr. Blakeney would show up off and on at my water polo or swim practices, and even attended a few swim meets. That meant a lot because, let’s face it, watching a high school swim meet is like watching paint dry.
I’m not saying Mr. Blakeney didn’t bust my balls. He did that plenty and, sometimes when I’d get in trouble with a group of friends, he came down harder on me than any of the rest of us. I really didn’t mind because I probably deserved it, but even more so, I knew he really cared.
At one point I had missed so much school there was nothing he could do, so he called me into his office one last time. We talked about sports for about 10-15 minutes before he got real serious and told me I wasn’t going to be able to graduate.
I remember trying to act disappointed but, honestly, the only reason I was even going to high school was for my friends and the one other person who meant so much to me: Mr Blakeney.
As I was walking back to my locker to clear out my books and dirty laundry, Mr. Blakeney gave me a big bear hug and said, “Listen, Ed. Not everyone is cut out for school but you’re going to be just fine. I promise you, before you’re 30 years old, you’re going to be a millionaire so hold your head up when you walk out of here.”
I cannot tell you how many times I’ve recounted that day in my life but I know it’s well over a thousand.
Bob Blakeney, may you rest in peace, and I sure hope you knew what an amazing presence you had here on this earth.
Ed St. George
Santa Barbara
• • •
Regarding Robert Sulnick’s March 21 commentary, “New Oil Drilling on Alaska’s North Slope an Environmental Disaster,” he makes three points:
- “This drilling project will result in 278 metric tons of greenhouse gases over a 30-year lifespan of the development, the equivalent of … running more than 70 coal-fired power plants for a year.”
Global greenhouse gas emissions are about 50 billion metric tons a year. 278 metric tons in 30 years is about 10 metric tons each year, less than 1-billionth of 1% of global emissions.
China is building about 100 coal-fired plants this year. Operating over 30 years they will produce 50 times the greenhouse gases the ConocoPhillips Willow Project will produce, not including additional coal-fired plants China might build over the next 29 years.
- “Climate change is killing people. It has already caused more than 5 million deaths, 9.4% of all deaths globally.”
These statements appear to be based on a 2021 report in The Lancet Planetary Health: “Global, regional and national burden of mortality associated with nonoptimal ambient temperatures from 2000 to 2019: a three-stage modeling study,” by professor Qi Zhao and 67 co-authors from all over the globe:
The Lancet study reports: “Globally, 5,083,173 deaths … associated with nonoptimal temperatures per year, accounting for 9.43% … of all deaths; 8.52% cold-related and 0.91% … heat-related.”
The study further reports: “From 2000-2003 to 2016-2019, the global excess death ratio changed by −0.51 percentage points for cold temperatures and increased by 0.21 percentage points for hot temperatures, resulting in a net decline of −0.30 percentage points.”
In the past 20 years, there were about 1 billion global deaths from all causes. 0.3% of 1 billion is 3 million. The Lancet study therefore concludes that 3 million lives were saved the past 20 years (150,000 per year) due to climate change!
- “Between 2030 and 2050, it (climate change) is expected to cause approximately 250,000 additional deaths per year from malnutrition, malaria, diarrhea and heat stress.”
That appears to be a quote from a World Health Organization fact sheet. WHO does not cite a source. If true, this is about 0.15% of global deaths.
Carl Schueler
Santa Barbara
• • •
Robert Sulnick’s commentaries are always educational, thoughtful, well-researched and a call to action for readers.
I agree that allowing this Alaska drilling project to go ahead will seriously delay our transition to clean energy.
This action by the Biden administration is shocking because it’s contrary to all its other efforts to mitigate the climate crisis. We can only assume that it came about as a result of the huge financial and political power of fossil fuel companies and their political allies.
The world already has more oil and gas than can be safely burned. Sulnick references the International Energy Agency’s determination that no new fossil fuel infrastructure can be built if the world is to avoid disastrous climate change tipping points.
We need to realize that fossil fuels are not our only option. Affordable, clean, renewable energy sources are already available to take their place. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change has concluded that the only real obstacles to the transition to a clean energy future are politics and fossil fuel interests.
The oil and gas industry is, arguably, the most financially and politically powerful force on earth. It is their greed, deceit and indifference that has brought us to where we are today.
Ultimately, it is down to us. We can decarbonize our lives by electrifying our homes and transport. Yet, while important, these actions alone won’t achieve our climate goals fast enough. We need elected officials to stand up to Big Oil and do the right thing.
Fortunately, Rep. Salud Carbajal, D-Santa Barbara, understands the urgency to act on the climate crisis. He has co-sponsored legislation that would tax fossil fuel companies on their carbon pollution, use the revenue to support families through the transition, and achieve a global solution by incentivizing all our trading partners, including China, to adopt similar policies.
Congressman Carbajal was also instrumental in getting the “Inflation Reduction Act” passed and his office is busy educating constituents about how to take advantage of clean energy subsidies.
Fossil fuel interests are powerful, but citizens have power, too. Let’s use it.
Bob Taylor
Montecito
• • •
In Frank Sanitate’s March 22 commentary, “Silicon Valley Bank Crash, Money and the Fear of Death,” he states that “the owners and executives of banks — those who got the bonuses — and rich people in general (not all) will always fund and vote for those who will protect their money.” Then he proceeds to say those politicians are “generally Republicans.”
I don’t know what century Sanitate is living in, but “rich people in general (not all)” are Democrats, and they only buy Democrat votes in the White House, Congress and the Legislature. The Silicon Valley Bank bailout is the latest case in point.
R. Phillips
Buellton
• • •
Mail Calls
Noozhawk welcomes and encourages expressions of all views on Santa Barbara County issues.
Letters should be BRIEF — as in 200 words-BRIEF — and letters under 150 words are given priority. Each must include a valid mailing address and contact information. Pseudonyms will not be used, and repeat letters will be skipped. Letters may be edited for clarity, length and style.
With rare exceptions, this feature is published on Saturdays.
By submitting any content to Noozhawk, you warrant that the material is your original expression, free of plagiarism, and does not violate any copyright, proprietary, contract or personal right of anyone else. Noozhawk reserves, at our sole discretion, the right to choose not to publish a submission.
Click here for Noozhawk’s Terms of Use, and click here for more information about how to submit letters to the editor and other announcements, tips and stories.

