UCSB's Ajay Mitchell holds his head after being knocked to the floor during Wednesday's first-round defeat to Cal State Northridge at the Big West Conference Basketball Tournament.
UCSB's Ajay Mitchell holds his head after being knocked to the floor during Wednesday's first-round defeat to Cal State Northridge at the Big West Conference Basketball Tournament. Credit: Big West Conference Photo

Overview:

UCSB’s season ends with its seventh defeat in the last 10 games

HENDERSON, Nev. — Ajay Mitchell was cracking open the Big West Conference Basketball Tournament record book on Wednesday when he got tripped up by a footnote at the Dollar Loan Center.

He crashed on his drive toward the basket — and history — after stepping on the foot of Cal State Northridge’s De’Sean Allen-Eikens.

Mitchell, whose 36 points had brought him to within one of the tournament record, never scored again after reinjuring his ankle during the first minute of overtime in an 87-84 defeat to Cal State Northridge in the first round of the league tournament.

“What he persevered through with his injuries (all season) was unbelievable,” Gaucho coach Joe Pasternack said. “It was a never-ending cycle, and tonight was a microcosm of it all.

“But he battles and battles, he makes no excuses, and I think he’s as good of a player as I’ve ever coached.”

The defeat was the final nail in the coffin of a Gaucho team that was voted overwhelmingly as the preseason favorite by the league’s coaches. UCSB (16-15) lost seven of its last 10 games.

“This is 100% on me,” Pasternack said. “I take full responsibility.

“We finished 16-15. The expectations for this basketball program are higher. It’s to compete for championships. We didn’t do that, and nobody has higher standards than me.”

The Matadors, meanwhile, celebrated their first Big West Tournament victory in a decade as though they won the championship game. CSUN (19-14) advanced to play Hawai’i in Thursday’s quarterfinals.

“This is what March is all about,” first-year coach Andy Newman gushed afterward. “Fun basketball and finishes like that.

“Man, strap in — it’s going to be a fun month.”

His Matadors out-shot the Gauchos 46.8% to 38.7% which included 42.1% from three-point range (8-for-19). They also out-rebounded UCSB, 43-41.

They jumped on the Gauchos from the start, taking a 14-5 lead after holding them scoreless during an early stretch of six minutes.

CSUN scored eight of its first 10 points off Gaucho turnovers — two which were committed by Mitchell.

The junior guard redeemed himself, however, with three consecutive threes in a matter of just 75 seconds.

UCSB’s Yohan Traore dunks off a drive during Wednesday’s Big West Conference Basketball Tournament opener against Cal State Northridge. (Big West Conference Photo)

Mitchell’s 36 points came on 10-of-21 shooting which included 5-of-12 three-pointers. He also made 11-of-12 free throws, grabbed nine rebounds, assisted five baskets and made three steals.

“Ajay Mitchell is the mentally toughest and physically toughest kid I’ve ever coached,” Pasternack said. “I’ve coached a lot of NBA lottery picks — one-and-dones — and what he went through this year is unbelievable.”

Josh Pierre-Louis turned a steal into a layup and Yohan Traore added two free throws to cap an 11-0 run that put UCSB ahead 18-14.

Neither team led by more than four points the rest of the first half.

Mitchell and Traore did nearly all the damage for the Gauchos in the first 20 minutes, combining for 33 of the team’s 39 points. Traore finished with 17 points.

Mitchell, who already shares UCSB’s single-game record of 39 points, reached his season average of 19 by halftime. He nudged UCSB ahead 39-38 with a free throw just before the break.

Another slow start put the Gauchos behind again in the second half, 50-41. They also bounced back again to tie the score at 50-all on Cole Anderson’s three.

UCSB’s roller-coaster evening began another downward spiral when Pierre-Louis fouled out with 10:21 still left and Northridge leading, 65-56.

“Josh is one of the winningest players in the history of the school,” Pasternack said. “Two NCAA Tournaments in three years — that’s really hard to do in a single-bid league.”

But Mitchell and Matija Belic, Pierre-Louis’ replacement, made back-to-back threes to rally the Gauchos to within 67-66.

A jumper by freshman Jason Fontenet II put UCSB ahead, 70-69.

CSUN took back the lead, however, on a three-point play by Allen-Eikins.

Keonte Jones kept the Matadors rolling by scoring six of his team-high 25 points in the last six minutes of regulation. His fast-break layup with 1:03 left gave them a 79-74 lead. Allen-Eikens added 24 points for CSUN.

“It was like nine games in one,” Newman said. “It was crazy … A crazy game. Well fought, two great teams getting after each other, making plays.”

Fontenet renewed Gaucho hopes with a three just 13 seconds later.

“Jason Fontenet played a lot of minutes this year as a freshman and gained a lot of experience,” Pasternack said. “He had nine rebounds tonight.”

After Jones missed a pair of free throws, Mitchell sent the game into overtime by making two foul shots with 11.4 seconds remaining.

Those, however, were the last points the Gaucho star would score.

Mitchell crashed to the floor after stepping on Allen-Eikens’ foot while driving toward the basket during the first minute of overtime. He missed all four of his shots after that, and his teammates missed all seven of theirs.

“The injuries, they’re part of the game,” Pasternack said. “You can’t control that. What happened tonight was kind of a microcosm of what we’ve had happen all year.”

Allen-Eikens’ runnner put CSUN ahead 85-80 with 40 seconds left in overtime.

A free throw by Traore and four straight missed foul shots by the Matadors gave UCSB a chance with 13.4 seconds on the clock.

Ben Shtolzberg was fouled attempting a three with 5.3 seconds to go. He made all three foul shots to reduce the CSUN lead to 85-84.

Allen-Eikens made two free throws with 4.3 seconds on the clock, however, and Shtolzberg’s attempt to send the game into a second overtime failed when his 27-foot shot rimmed out at the buzzer.

“Our guys really, really battled to the bitter end tonight, no matter what the circumstances were,” Pasternack said.

Noozhawk sports columnist and correspondent Mark Patton is a longtime local sports writer. Contact him at sports@noozhawk.com.