First and foremost, I’d like to congratulate Santa Barbara County’s new Fifth District supervisor, Ricardo Valencia.

His victory over Maribel Aguilera was the result of an effective campaign engineered by the Santa Barbara County Democratic Central Committee, the Democratic Women of Santa Barbara, and the endorsements of Assemblyman Gregg Hart, Supervisors Laura Capps and Joan Hartmann, and rent control activist and Santa Barbara City Councilwoman Wendy Santamaria.

But perhaps the individuals who contributed most to Valencia’s victory are retiring Fifth District Supervisor Steve Lavagnino and his longtime chief of staff, Cory Bantilan, who lost his bid for the post in the June 2 primary.

Christian Alonso, the rather sharp Santa Barbara County Democratic Party chairman, called Lavagnino’s retirement after 16 years a “generational opportunity” to change the balance of power in the county. He was absolutely correct.

Lavagnino’s voting record was neither conservative nor predictable, but at times he played to the center with a deft sense of humor and natural ability to string a sentence together.

But we need to ask about his legacy, not in the Fifth District where he did some good (e.g., Hope Village and Santa Maria River flood abatement), but throughout the county.

As part of the so called “Doobie Brothers,” he and then-First District Supervisor Das Williams formed a secretive two-man committee that developed our sweeping countywide cannabis ordinance and failed tax scheme.

The cannabis ordinance has been universally criticized as one of the worst pieces of public policy legislation in the entire state, ceding unlimited control to the county Planning & Development Department to approve individual grower odor abatement plans.

Even cannabis-friendly publications objectively summarized the 2020 civil grand jury as “blasting the Santa Barbara County Board of Supervisors for its mismanagement of the county’s cannabis production, for dismissing public input, ignoring major environmental impacts, and allowing excessive production.”

The grand jury report continued, saying “instead of a balanced approach carefully evaluating how the cannabis industry would be compatible, both as to amount of acreage and location, the board simply opened the floodgates.”

Fun Fact: Santa Barbara County increased its 2026 cannabis production by a whopping 40% (value was up 28%) to 14 million pounds. Who says the industry is not thriving?

According to the 2024-2025 grand jury, the county now deficit-subsidizes cannabis to the tune of about $5 million per year.

Aside from this largesse, there was the political impact. When in 2020 Williams, with some behind-the-scenes help from Bantilan, defeated Capps on his way to re-election, PAC advertising and direct cannabis contributions flowed, creating an insurmountable funding deficit for the challenger.

This pattern repeated itself in the June primary earlier this year when Bantilan, with the blessing of Lavagnino, ran on the positivity of cannabis and was supported with cannabis and Lavagnino funding.

Bantilan, like Aguilera, was an independent and competed for the same voters in a predominantly Democratic Fifth District.

For obvious reasons, Bantilan was a long shot, who nonetheless captured 26% of the vote to Aguilera’s 31%. In other words, had Lavagnino endorsed Aguilera in the primary, the Santa Maria city councilwoman likely would have captured at least 57% of the vote — meaning no general election in the fall. Game over.

Following the primary, Lavagnino refused to endorse Aguilera and instead sat on the sidelines for what was the most consequential county election in nearly 20 years.

I know character when I see it and for a supervisor who served 16 years and will now be collecting a hefty pension, this is the antithesis of character.

So, yes, aside from cannabis, apathetic petulance is now also part of Lavagnino’s legacy.

As someone who supported Aguilera and the idea of balance on the Board of Supervisors, I tip my cap to Team Valencia, who did what one would have expected them to do.

It’s just unfortunate that Team Lavagnino/Bantilan didn’t do the same.

Jeff Giordano is a co-founder of the Spotlight Santa Barbara speaker series and a leading community voice on cannabis regulation, grand jury findings and public finances. The opinions expressed are his own.