A move to extend what was promised to be a temporary rent freeze has pushed some property owners to the edge, and they blasted the Santa Barbara City Council during Tuesday’s meeting.
As a referendum seeks to throw out the city’s rent stabilization ordinance that was set to go into effect in January, the council voted 4-2 Tuesday to extend the moratorium on rent increases until the referendum process is finalized.
Members Kristen Sneddon, Meagan Harmon, Wendy Santamaria and Oscar Gutierrez voted for it, Mayor Randy Rowse and Eric Friedman voted against the move, and Mike Jordan was absent.
The temporary rent freeze was adopted in January. It covers residential rental units established on or before Feb. 1, 1995. It was passed while the City Council developed the permanent rent stabilization ordinance.
The ordinance, approved last month, limits annual rent increases and creates a rental unit registry overseen by the city. A group submitted petition signatures to challenge the ordinance, and the County Elections Office is reviewing that list.
On Tuesday, landlords demanded that the council not supersede the referendum process, arguing that the move to extend the temporary ordinance after the referendum was filed goes against the democratic process.
Mimi Greenberg made some threatening comments as she called the council’s actions an “abuse of political power” and compared the rent freeze extension to“theft.”
“The four of you should be handcuffed and escorted out the back door,” Greenberg said. “And just an FYI, that not so many years ago, thieves were hung in this town.”
Her comment provoked a look of concern and surprise from some council members and a look of amusement from others.

Santamaria denounced Greenberg’s comment toward the end of the hearing, calling it “appalling political violence” that has no place in Santa Barbara.
“We need to make sure that after this referendum we’re still going to work together, we’re still going to live in this city so we really need to be careful about the political violence that we are articulating,” Santamaria said.
Sean Alexander said not extending the rent freeze was about “basic fairness” to landlords. He repeated many concerns by fellow landlords about feeling excluded from the ordinance process, arguing it was developed with only the Santa Barbara Tenants Union in mind.
Carol Bowman said the rent at her three units is a few hundred dollars below market value, leaving her unable to afford fixing the roof, reducing the property value by $300,000.
“We’re screwed, we can’t retire,” Bowman said after slamming her hands down on the podium.
She went on to say that the city should focus on going after larger corporate landlords rather than individuals.
“This is robbery,” Bowman said.

The rent freeze extension does include an option for landlords to petition a fair rate of return.
Stanley Tzankov, co-founder of the Santa Barbara Tenants Union, argued that without the extension, tenants could face up to an 8.6% rent increase.
“For someone who’s already struggling to stay housed in this economy, with this federal administration, and with this hostile housing market, that could be the breaking point,” Tzankov said.
Tenant advocates argued that landlords did have chances to weigh in at the numerous public meetings for the ordinance, argued that signature gatherers used misleading tactics to earn signatures, and that voters made their wishes clear by electing a new mayor and three council members who support rent stabilization.
“If it’s an indicator of how undemocratic it would be to cancel this rent freeze, every single candidate who ran on a pro RSO (rent stabilization ordinance) this past election won their race and in many cases by a wide margin,” said Beckett Staubs.

The rent control referendum petition is backed by the Santa Barbara Rental Property Association, a vocal opponent of rent control. It sued the city in April over the temporary rent control ordinance.
That petition was submitted to the city earlier this month with 9,100 signatures, organizers announced. It needs 5,483 signatures to qualify.
The City Council’s permanent ordinance, adopted 4-3 in October, limits how much landlords can raise rents. It also creates a rental property registry and a seven-person rent-stabilization board that will oversee the program.
Mayor-elect Kristen Sneddon said the city should have extended the rent freeze while they spent more time working on the rent stabilization ordinance, but now during the referendum process, the city can’t make changes to the ordinance.
“It’s a very frustrating position to be in,” Sneddon said.
Santamaria said she’s happy to see the ordinance go to voters, especially after pro-rent stabilization council candidates were just elected.
“But for now we don’t have another option other than to make sure we are protecting families from displacement,” Santamaria said. “I personally would not be able to sleep at night knowing that we’d essentially be sacrificing families to homelessness in the interim if we decided to do nothing while the legal battles play out.”
Friedman argued that the council majority should have tried to come to a compromise with himself and councilmember Jordan, and if they had, they might not be in this position now.
Rowse said landlords were not taken seriously during the ordinance process and should have been included more.
“Not only are there tenants living on the edge, there are small property owners living on the edge right now that are really in the hurt locker because of what we’ve done,” Rowse said. “And now we want to extend something based on our own faux paus.”

Under the permanent ordinance that the referendum is challenging, rent increases are limited to once within a 12-month period at a maximum of 3% or 60% of the rise of the Consumer Price Index — whichever is lower.
State rules currently limit yearly rent increases to 5% plus a cost-of-living increase, with a maximum of 10%. In Santa Barbara County, the maximum yearly rent increase allowed under the state rule is 8.6%.
The city limits on rent increases do not apply to units constructed after Feb. 1, 1995, government-owned and operated units, privately owned single-family homes, condos and townhomes, and mobile home parks.
Early estimates say administering the rental registry program will cost the city at least $2 million per year.

