A rendering of a for-rent, income-restricted housing project proposed for Carpinteria's S&S Seeds property at 6155 and 6175 Carpinteria Ave.
A rendering of a for-rent, income-restricted housing project proposed for Carpinteria's S&S Seeds property at 6155 and 6175 Carpinteria Ave. Credit: Central Coast CA Ventures LLC rendering

The development team behind a multi-family housing development proposed for the Carpinteria Bluffs has put forth alternative plans that would increase the number of units and put the income-restricted portion onto another parcel.

Initial builder’s remedy plans for 5885 Carpinteria Ave. included 191 for-sale, two-story residences: 94 townhomes and 97 single-family homes. Of those, 20 single-family homes and 19 townhomes would be designated as income-restricted units.

Under the alternative proposal, Central Coast CA Ventures LLC would put 175 market-rate, two-story single-family homes and 67 townhomes at 5885 Carpinteria Ave.

Forty-two of the single-family homes would have junior accessory dwelling units. There would be 621 parking spaces.

A 20-space public parking lot would be built for visitors of the Carpinteria Bluffs Nature Preserve.

On the mountainside of the railroad tracks, plans include an open space buffer and trails, with a 200-foot setback from the railroad.

Below that parcel on the ocean side of the railroad tracks is 5669 Carpinteria Ave., which offers community members and visitors access to a site to view Carpinteria’s seal sanctuary.

Under the alternative, the development team would dedicate that space to the city as permanent open space.

The site at 5885 Carpinteria Ave. is currently home to the Tee Time Practice Center and the Carp Farm School.

The team would increase and move the income-restricted units down the road to 6155 and 6175 Carpinteria Ave. — the S&S Seeds side — with 87 income-restricted units and one manager’s unit in two-story, 30-foot-high buildings.

There would be 93 parking spaces.

The income-restricted units would serve low-income populations. They would also become rental units rather than for-sale properties under the alternative, managed by People’s Self-Help Housing.

At 6155 Carpinteria Ave. is an industrial building, while 6175 Carpinteria Ave. is currently undeveloped.

Roughly half of the S&S Seeds site would be redeveloped into open space, and a portion of the parcel would be dedicated to the city. An educational children’s farm and school, as well as a new 41-space parking lot for bluffs access and new trail connections, also would be built.

Read the full breakdown of the project from city staff here.

People’s Self-Help Housing and Victor Shaff, owner of the S&S Seeds parcel, are in support of the alternative, according to letters submitted to the city.

Shaff had submitted his own concept for bluffs development last year to the city, but the council, at that time, declined to rezone the parcel for high-density housing.

Carpinteria’s current four People’s Self-Help Housing developments with 160 units have 800 people on the waiting list, according to People’s Self-Help Housing CEO and President Kenneth Trigueiro.

Developer Paul Brenneke said in a statement that he believes the alternative “demonstrates that housing and preservation do not have to be competing
priorities” in Carpinteria.

“Over the past several years, I’ve had the opportunity to spend considerable time listening to the residents of Carpinteria. I appreciate the time people have taken to share their perspectives, concerns and ideas with us. One thing that has become very clear is how deeply people care about preserving what makes Carpinteria special,” he wrote.

“We’ve heard from those who are concerned about new development and its impact on the community. But we’ve also heard from those who recognize the critical shortage of housing, particularly affordable housing, and worry about whether their children and future generations will be able to afford to live here. I understand and appreciate both perspectives.”

Carpinteria residents historically have been hesitant to develop the bluffs.

The Citizens for the Carpinteria Bluffs — an advocacy group that for decades has been dedicated to bluffs preservation — on Friday denounced the alternative.

Constructing new housing units on the bluffs “completely changes Carpinteria, damages carefully protected environmental preserves, pushes development outside of current uses and disregards decades of planning,” the group wrote.

The City Council on Monday will consider an agreement between the development team and the city that would allow the city to study the alternative under the state’s environmental review laws.

If the council approves the agreement, the draft environmental impact report could be available by September 2027, according to city staff.

The Planning Commission could consider the project in March 2028, and the City Council at the end of April 2028, under the tentative timeline released this week.

The City Council meets at 5:30 p.m. at Carpinteria City Hall, 5775 Carpinteria Ave.

— Noozhawk South County editor Evelyn Spence can be reached at espence@noozhawk.com. Follow Noozhawk on Twitter: @noozhawk, @NoozhawkNews and @NoozhawkBiz. Connect with Noozhawk on Facebook.