Tatiana Speier, who has worked at Cottage for five years, says many nurses live "paycheck to paycheck." She is pictured above at an Oct. 23 press conference.
Tatiana Speier, who has worked at Cottage for five years, says many nurses live "paycheck to paycheck." She is pictured above at an Oct. 23 press conference. Credit: Evelyn Spence / Noozhawk photo

With the Cottage Health nurses union vote right around the corner, some employees have alleged that the healthcare organization has violated labor laws governing their right to hold a union vote.

Nurses announced their intent to hold a union vote with SEIU Local 121RN at an Oct. 23 press conference. They said they want to unionize because of wage transparency, high costs of living, high pay for executives and recent changes to the leave policy.

All regular full-time, part-time and per-diem registered nurses employed at Goleta Valley Cottage Hospital, Santa Barbara Cottage Hospital and Cottage Rehabilitation Hospital will have the chance to vote in a union election. That includes 1,153 nurses at Santa Barbara, 103 at Goleta Valley and 40 at the rehabilitation hospital.

In filings Friday with the National Labor Relations Board, SEIU Local 121RN alleges that Cottage Health has threatened to decrease employees’ wages and benefits and withhold regular pay increases if nurses unionize, and promised improved benefits to employees if they don’t unionize, among other allegations.

Scroll down to view a copy of that filing.

Cottage Health spokeswoman Cristina Cortez denied the allegations to Noozhawk.

“Whether to be represented by a union is our nurses’ decision, and we respect their right to choose. We disagree with these claims,” she said via email on Tuesday.

“Cottage is a special place to work because our nurses, staff and leaders have a long history of working together directly to address concerns and find solutions. We encourage every eligible nurse to vote so all voices are represented.

“Whatever the outcome, we will continue working alongside our nurses to care for the community we serve.”

She referred Noozhawk to an FAQ website created by Cottage Health about the unionizing process.

Emergency room nurse Clare Upton and oncology nurse Dianna Hosley told Noozhawk this week that they were disappointed by Cottage Health’s response to unionization.

Nurse Tatiana Speier said a poster that Cottage Health posted around the hospital said that regular raises are not guaranteed if nurses unionize. Speier said evaluations done in the fall impact raises in the spring.

Cortez previously told Noozhawk that nurses have received consistent raises during the past few years: 6% in 2022, 6.3% in 2023, 5.4% in 2024, 6.3% in 2025 and 6.3% in 2026.

A union spokesperson provided Noozhawk a digital copy of the poster, which stated: “If a union is voted in, it could mean no pay raises for years while a contract is negotiated. Pay and benefits are frozen from now until this is over.”

The FAQ page Cottage Health created states that “union representation does not automatically increase pay or improve benefits. If nurses select a union, Cottage and the union would negotiate over those issues in good faith.”

Speier alleged that those on the management level have been writing down the names of nurses and technicians who visit the union tables outside of the hospital, and that management-level staff who typically would not visit the nursing areas have been doing so since the unionizing effort began.

There’s “lots of fear,” she said.

Hosley said an email sent out to staff last week stated that the “raises that we’ve come to expect every January are not automatic, despite that having been the case for the entire 12 years” she has worked for the hospital.

“We feel strongly that if we were not to get our raises this year, this would be direct retaliation for us organizing,” she said.

Upton said she was “sad” that Cottage would “publish something that says, ‘Yeah, your raises might be in jeopardy.'”

When asked about the allegation that Cottage promised benefits in exchange for not unionizing, each of the three nurses said they did not have direct knowledge about it. Speier said she heard secondhand that Cottage promised higher raises if nurses did not unionize.

A union spokesperson could not provide Noozhawk with a direct example of when Cottage may have promised benefits in exchange for not unionizing.

The union is required to provide evidence of the allegations to the National Labor Relations Board by Nov. 27.

Cortez said Cottage takes “our obligations under federal labor law seriously and will respond to them through the NLRB’s process.”

A copy of Friday’s filings with the National Labor Relations Board in which SEIU Local 121RN alleges Cottage Health has violated labor laws governing nurses’ right to hold a union vote. Cottage Health has denied the allegations. Contributed by SEIU Local 121RN

— Noozhawk South County editor Evelyn Spence can be reached at espence@noozhawk.com. Follow Noozhawk on Twitter: @noozhawk, @NoozhawkNews and @NoozhawkBiz. Connect with Noozhawk on Facebook.