Start with the columns in the old postcard. Above them is a triangular pediment, and behind them rises a domed cupola.
The building looks like a declaration of civic importance. It takes a moment to recognize it as part of Santa Barbara.
It was our Santa Barbara County courthouse. Published by M. Rieder between 1905 and 1909, the postcard preserves a building very different from the one visitors know today.
If you want to stand where the old courthouse stood, go to the Sunken Garden along East Anapamu Street.
You may find people waiting for a wedding to start. They’ll be looking toward a courthouse that tells a very different story about Santa Barbara.
The county’s first courthouse on that block was a store. In 1855 the county bought John Kayes’ adobe mercantile building and put it to work as a courthouse.
Fifteen years later, the civil grand jury thought the place was a disgrace. The county was outgrowing the adobe, and its officials wanted a building with the stature of the courthouses familiar to Americans who had come West.
The county chose local architect Peter J. Barber. The cornerstone was laid in 1872, and county officials were using the offices by early 1875.
Barber laid out the building in the form of a Greek cross, with a domed cupola over the central space. On East Figueroa Street, a pediment and columns announced the entrance from above street level.
Inside were courtrooms, judges’ chambers and county offices. The county added a stone jail and, as government grew, a separate Hall of Records.
For a half-century the building in the postcard was where much of the county’s public business got done.
Early on June 29, 1925, an earthquake shook hard enough to bring down the Santa Barbara Mission’s twin towers. A dam in the foothills failed, releasing millions of gallons of water.
A gas company engineer shut off the city’s gas supply, helping spare Santa Barbara the kind of fires that had followed San Francisco’s 1906 earthquake.
At the courthouse, a column broke and part of the jail collapsed. The Hall of Records was badly damaged as well.
The county had already held a competition for a new courthouse in 1919, but it hadn’t been ready to pay for one.
By 1924, the rebuilt Lobero Theatre was showing what Spanish Colonial Revival could look like in a prominent public building.
Four days after the quake, supervisors hired William Mooser & Co., a finalist in the earlier competition, and specified a Spanish Andalusian design.
The shock lasted seconds. The decision about what the city should look like had been years in the making.
The new design took some arguing. Local architectural reviewers objected to the Mooser firm’s first proposal.
J. Wilmer Hershey, working with the local Community Drafting Room, sketched revisions that helped shape the accepted design. Mooser publicly credited his contribution.
Hershey died in 1926 at 32, before he could see the building go up.
Voters approved a bond in 1926. When the bond money ran out, tax revenue from oil-bearing land at Ellwood helped cover the cost.
Behind the white plaster and sandstone was a steel frame built to withstand earthquakes.
The county dedicated the courthouse on Aug. 14, 1929, at the opening of Old Spanish Days Fiesta. It looked back to a Spanish past and depended on some very modern engineering and finance.
Walk under the great arch today and you can see how much the architects did with the space between the street and the courtroom. There are tiled stairways and wrought-iron grilles, and from the clock tower you can look back toward the Mission.
The Mural Room, now used for weddings and public events, was originally where the county supervisors met.
Painter Dan Sayre Groesbeck had worked as a set designer in Hollywood. Imagine trying to follow a budget debate with that much going on above your head.
Santa Barbara already knew how to welcome visitors. The original Arlington Hotel opened in 1875, and rail service to Los Angeles helped make the city a winter resort.
The courthouse made its public debut at Fiesta, and by the early 1940s it was on a postcard. A place where people went to file papers or answer a summons had also become a place worth writing home about.
There’s a small irony in the county’s architectural history. In the 1870s, it traded an adobe for the columns of an American civic building.
Half a century later, a different generation of officials turned back toward the region’s Spanish past to give its new courthouse a character of its own.
Each building expressed what its builders wanted Santa Barbara to become.
I’m glad we have the Sunken Garden. There’s something generous about giving over the ground where a courthouse once stood to people who want to sit outside, take a photograph or get married.
But I like keeping that old postcard in mind when I’m there.
From the lawn, you can look up at the tower everyone recognizes. Then look down at the grass and picture, just for a moment, the long row of columns.

