Following my first Noozhawk article about two bosses who influenced my understanding of leadership, a reader shared a difficult employment experience.

The reader accepted a management position with an organization whose mission was personally meaningful. But within the first month, disagreements with a supervisor and warnings about performance began. Despite efforts to address the difficulties, the employment relationship ended after just three months.

The reader asked how to rebuild professional confidence and find an organization that would value their experience.

It’s a question worth considering for anyone who hires, supervises, or works with others.

The First 90 Days Are a Two-Way Evaluation

There’s a familiar saying in management: “Hire slow and fire fast.”

Organizations should be thoughtful about hiring and recognize when an employment relationship isn’t working. But acting quickly shouldn’t mean acting carelessly.

When employees struggle, supervisors should ask: Did we communicate clear expectations? Provide adequate training and resources? Offer constructive feedback and a fair opportunity to succeed?

Too often, organizations evaluate employees without examining their own responsibilities.

But employees have responsibilities, too.

I frequently remind job seekers that you are evaluating the employer just as much as the employer is evaluating you.

During interviews, everyone puts their best foot forward. Only after working together do we discover what the relationship is really like.

The first few months should be an opportunity for both parties to determine whether the relationship is mutually beneficial.

Workplace Culture Is More Than a Mission Statement

Organizations often describe their cultures using words like respect, collaboration, and integrity. But culture isn’t defined by a website. It’s demonstrated through everyday behavior.

Consider two supervisors responding to an employee’s mistake.

One asks, “What happened, and what can we do differently next time?”

The other immediately threatens disciplinary action.

Both may be addressing performance, but their approaches create very different workplace environments.

Accountability is essential. Employees need clear expectations and must take responsibility for meeting them.

But accountability and dignity are not mutually exclusive.

Good leaders recognize that how we address problems is often as important as the problems themselves.

When Is It Time to Move On?

Something struck me about this reader’s experience: how quickly the reader became invested in making the position work despite warning signs.

That’s understandable. We want to succeed, and walking away can feel like admitting defeat.

But accepting a job isn’t a lifetime commitment.

Employment is a marketplace. Employers make decisions based on organizational needs, and employees have every right to make decisions based on their professional and personal needs.

I often tell job seekers: Accept a position that meets your needs, but continue exploring opportunities. If something better comes along, there’s nothing unethical about pursuing it.

Professionalism matters. So does recognizing when an employment relationship isn’t working.

Loyalty should be a two-way relationship, not an obstacle to making sound career decisions.

Moving Forward With Confidence

We don’t know all the circumstances surrounding this reader’s experience, and assigning blame based on one perspective would be unfair.

But unsuccessful employment relationships offer lessons for everyone.

Employers should examine their hiring, onboarding, and supervisory practices. Employees should reflect on their experiences without allowing one difficult situation to define their professional worth.

For those navigating career transitions, America’s Job Centers of California (AJCC) offer no-cost career assistance in Santa Barbara, Santa Maria, and San Luis Obispo.

Ultimately, successful employment relationships require mutual respect, clear expectations, effective communication, and opportunities to contribute and grow.

The goal shouldn’t simply be to hire the right person. It should be to create an environment where the right person can succeed.

And for employees, the goal isn’t simply to find an organization willing to hire you, but one where you can do your best work.

Have you experienced a workplace culture that brought out the best in you—or made it difficult to succeed? I’d welcome your thoughts and questions for future articles at kathy@marcovetraining.com.