
The red state-blue state divide seems deeper than ever. We are divided by gun control, abortion, voting rights, LGBTQ rights, book banning and climate change.
Acceptance of the scientific consensus that climate change is human caused is now caught up with these culture war issues, with 78% of Democrats seeing climate change as a top priority versus only 21% of Republicans.
The reality, of course, is that regardless of where we live, the devastating effects of climate change will continue to impact us. The irony here is that, according to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, the five worst states facing climate disasters are all politically red: Florida, Mississippi, Louisiana, Texas and Arkansas.
There is another irony that should not be ignored. Red states are responding to climate change, they’re just not calling it climate change.
In 2019, the Arkansas Legistlature passed state Senate Bill 145, the Solar Access Act, which removed the state’s ban on leasing land for solar farms. A Republican legislator who introduced the bill said, “It’s a great day for the Arkansas consumer, they will have more choices in the market now.”
The Utah Legislature passed House Bill 411, the Community Renewable Energy Act, which created incentives to adopt a goal of meeting their net electricity needs with 100% renewable power by 2030. A Republican legislator who sponsored that bill said his motivation was not about climate change but about “letting the free market innovate.”
South Carolina has made it easier for solar power to be developed. Montana, North Dakota, Ohio and Texas have all embraced wind power, not because of its low carbon impact, but because it is cheaper than conventional fossil fuel power.
Between 2015 and 2020, there were 418 climate bills passed in legislatures throughout the United States, nearly a third of them by Republican-controlled state governments.
While none of these Republican bills addressed the root problem of fossil fuel emissions causing global warming, they — assuming the Senate won’t eliminate the filibuster and there are not enough Senate Democrats to pass anti-fossil fuel legislation, are a blueprint for fighting climate change.
As long as we continue to pump carbon into our atmosphere, nature and market-based solutions by themselves, even if adopted worldwide, will not stop the devastating impacts of global warming.
However, for Democrats to approach Republicans on the basis of market and nature-based actions could be a first step.
It could even lead to the United States developing such things as a carbon tax, clean energy tax incentives, incentives for electricity suppliers to increase clean energy, electrification of the federal fleet, rehabbing federal buildings with energy-saving measures, and ensuring climate change research.
It’s a certainty that climate caused natural disasters will continue. Given that they will continue to impact red states, maybe all it would take is a change in vernacular to create bipartisan support. What do we have to lose by trying?
— Environmental lawyer Robert Sulnick represented the community of Casmalia in litigation against the Casmalia Resources Hazardous Waste Landfill, co-founded the American Oceans Campaign with Ted Danson, and is a partner in the Santa Barbara environmental consulting firm Environmental Problem Solving Enterprises. Click here for previous columns. The opinions expressed are his own.
