November and December are make-or-break months for retailers. Holiday spending accounts for about 19% of the U.S. retail industry’s annual sales, and an even larger share for some chains.

Investors treat the season as a referendum on the American consumer, and retail stocks often move on every Black Friday headline.

Over the past five years, though, the link between strong holiday sales and a rising stock market has been much looser than the headlines suggest.

5 Seasons in Review

2021: The stimulus boom. Fueled by COVID-19 pandemic savings and government payments, holiday sales jumped 12.6%, a pace not seen since. Stocks joined the party: the S&P 500 rose about 5% during the Santa Claus rally window from Dec. 24, 2021, to Jan. 4, 2022. It was a false signal. The index fell 19.4% in 2022.

2022: Inflation bites. With prices near 40-year highs, Target warned in mid-November of a surprise drop in holiday-quarter sales, and its shares fell 17%. Consumer discretionary stocks were already down 32% for the year. Holiday sales still hit a record $929.5 billion, but the S&P 500 lost 5.9% in December.

2023: A return to normal. Holiday sales rose 3.8% to $964.4 billion, roughly matching the 3.6% pre-pandemic average. The market shrugged: the S&P 500 slipped 0.9% during the Santa Claus window, then gained more than 23% in 2024.

2024: An upside surprise. Sales grew an “unexpectedly high” 4% to $994.1 billion, beating the National Retail Federation (NRF) forecast of 2.5% to 3.5%. Stocks went the other way. The S&P 500 fell 2.4% in December, its first failed Santa rally since 2015, even as it finished the year up 23.3%.

2025: Mixed signals. Early credit card spending data showed 4.1% growth, but NRF’s later tally, based on government data, put growth at 3.1% to $972 billion, short of its forecast. Shoppers chased value, lifting off-price chains such as TJ Maxx and Ross while Target’s sales fell. The S&P 500 lost 0.3% in the Santa Claus window, its third straight negative showing, a first since at least 1950.

What to Expect in 2026

Forecasters are upbeat. NRF expects holiday sales to grow 4.2% to $1.013 trillion, which would be the fastest growth since 2021 and the first time the season tops $1 trillion on its measure.

NRF’s chief economist says nearly half of that gain should come from real spending growth rather than higher prices.

Adobe projects online holiday sales will climb 6.7% to a record $275.1 billion, with Cyber Monday expected to pass $15 billion for the first time.

The risks are familiar. Higher food and gasoline prices are squeezing moderate-income households, and NRF says spending growth is split by income, with higher-income households driving most of the gains.

That split favors value chains and luxury sellers over the middle of the market. This is the essence of a “K-shaped” economy — the lower arm of the “K” represents the lower income consumer, that is living paycheck to paycheck, while the upper arm represents upper income/wealthy consumers who can still afford to buy whatever they like.

The next few days will set the tone. Target reports Nov. 18, Walmart Nov. 19 and Best Buy Nov. 24, the last big retail earnings before Black Friday.

Their holiday guidance will likely move retail stocks more than any sales total released in January.

The Bottom Line

If the forecasts hold, 2026 will be the strongest holiday season in five years. History says that this alone will not lift the market.

Investors should watch retailers’ guidance this week, early Black Friday and Cyber Monday tallies, and the gap between value chains and midtier stores.

They should also watch whether a Santa Claus rally returns after three straight misses.

Last year also showed that early spending reads can be revised down once the government data arrive.

A strong season is good news for shoppers and some retailers.

For the broader stock market, it has been a weak predictor. One key indictor is whether stocks pull back in the September/October timeframe.

In years where this has occurred, stocks tend to rally into the end of the year with stronger upside performance.

We have had a significant pullback this year, especially within the technology sector. If retail sales come in as expected, we could see a strong rally, particularly in those technology names, and for the overall indexes.

Craig Allen, owner of Allen Wealth Management, is a Santa Barbara–based attorney and registered investment adviser with more than 35 years of experience in investment banking, financial planning and corporate counsel. The opinions expressed are his own.